Sonia’s Memoir: Savarkar’s Grandnephew Considers Legal Action, But No Book Ban

Date:

Satyaki Savarkar says he would first cross-check the statements and references to the Hindutva icon before deciding whether to pursue legal proceedings

 NEW DELHI — Satyaki Savarkar, the grandnephew of Hindutva ideologue Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, on Thursday said he was consulting his legal team over remarks about his great-uncle in Congress leader Sonia Gandhi’s recently released memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love. He said he could initiate legal proceedings if the statements were found to have no factual basis, but clarified that he was not seeking a ban on the book at this stage.

Satyaki is the son of Ashok Savarkar and belongs to the family through his paternal grandfather, Narayan Damodar Savarkar, who was the brother of VD Savarkar. He has worked in the information technology sector and has also been associated with activities promoting Savarkar’s legacy, including the Har Ghar Savarkar campaign.

Speaking to the media in Pune, Satyaki said he had not read the memoir in its entirety as he was travelling in Karnataka to deliver a speech on Savarkar. However, he had read some pages that mentioned his great-uncle and found that a couple of statements did not carry references.

“I have not read the book entirely as I was travelling in Karnataka to give a speech on Veer Savarkar. I have read a few pages which have named Veer Savarkar ji, and what I have found is that there are a couple of sentences. However, there is no reference given,” he said.

He added that he was discussing the matter with his lawyers and would decide on the next course of action after verifying the claims.

“Currently, I am in discussion with the legal team and advocate. After the discussion, if I find there is no truth in those statements made, I am free to initiate legal proceedings against Sonia Gandhi,” he said.

Satyaki also made it clear that he was not demanding that the book be banned. He said he would first cross-check the statements and references before deciding whether to pursue legal proceedings.

“I don’t think this is related to demanding any kind of ban because I have not read the book. I will cross-check the statements and references that are made, and I’ll do the proceedings legally but will not demand a ban as of now,” he added.

His position stands in contrast to the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena, which on Wednesday demanded a Maharashtra-wide ban on the memoir and tore pages from copies of the book at a press conference in Mumbai.

The Two Passages at the Centre of the Row

The controversy has centred on two passages in the memoir, appearing on pages 201 and 443.

In the first, Sonia Gandhi refers to Savarkar and other senior RSS ideologues in the context of mercy petitions submitted to the British colonial authorities. The passage says:

“While Congress freedom fighters were enduring assaults and imprisonment at the hands of the British rulers, senior ideologues of the RSS like Vinayak Damodar Savarkar were writing mercy petitions to their colonial masters, and their members were colluding with the British authorities as informers.”

The second passage discusses Savarkar as the founder of Hindutva ideology and describes his vision of India as one in which Hindus held a position of supremacy. It also links this outlook to the RSS, the BJP and their affiliated organisations.

Shiv Sena leaders, including Shaina N C, Sanjay Nirupam and Anand Dubey, alleged that the passages insult Savarkar and Marathi identity, and demanded that publisher HarperCollins remove pages 201 and 443 and stop circulation of the book in Maharashtra until changes are made.

Protest Backfires

The Shinde Sena’s protest on Wednesday took an unexpected turn when spokespersons, while tearing copies of the memoir, inadvertently tore a paper carrying a photograph of party founder Bal Thackeray.

Shaina N C later rejected allegations that she had deliberately insulted Thackeray and warned of legal action against those circulating the footage.

The incident drew criticism from the Congress, the Uddhav Thackeray-led Shiv Sena (UBT) and the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), who accused the Shinde faction of disrespecting its own founder. Maharashtra Congress president Nana Patole called the protesters a “bunch of ignoramuses.”

The Book and its Launch

Belonging: A Journey of Love, published in India by HarperCollins India, was released on November 10. The 544-page memoir traces Sonia Gandhi’s journey from Italy to India, her marriage to Rajiv Gandhi, her personal losses and her decades in politics.

It was formally launched at a public event in New Delhi on November 16, with her children Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra by her side. Publisher HarperCollins said the memoir had sold two lakh copies in less than a week of its release.

The book has also drawn political attacks from the BJP, which called the launch a “self-goal” and accused the Congress of seeking to whitewash its record. It contains other controversial passages as well, including Sonia Gandhi’s account of former President Pranab Mukherjee’s reported desire to become prime minister.

Why the Mercy Petitions Remain Contested

The mercy petitions are among the most debated episodes in Savarkar’s life, and historians continue to differ on how they should be interpreted.

Savarkar was arrested in London in 1910, brought to India, and sentenced in 1910-11 to two life terms totalling 50 years in the Nasik conspiracy case linked to the assassination of a British official. He was taken to the Cellular Jail in Port Blair on July 4, 1911.

While held in the Cellular Jail between 1911 and 1921, Savarkar submitted several petitions to the British Government of India seeking release, including petitions dated August 30, 1911, November 14, 1913, and March 30, 1920, besides others in 1914 and 1917.

He was moved to prisons on the Indian mainland in May 1921, first to Ratnagiri and later to Yerwada in Pune, and was released conditionally in 1924.

Supporters of Savarkar argue that the petitions were a tactical move to secure release and continue political work, and point to claims that Mahatma Gandhi had advised Savarkar to file such petitions. Critics argue that the petitions amounted to pledges of loyalty and submission to colonial authority, and contrast them with Congress leaders who refused to seek clemency.

Savarkar went on to write Hindutva: Who is a Hindu? in 1923, the text that laid out his definition of Hindutva and became foundational to Hindu nationalist politics.

Satyaki’s Earlier Case Against Rahul

Satyaki has previously been in the news for filing a criminal defamation complaint against Congress leader Rahul Gandhi over remarks Gandhi allegedly made about Savarkar during a speech in London in March 2023.

He filed the complaint in Pune in April 2023. According to the complaint, Gandhi allegedly claimed at an Overseas Congress event in London on March 5, 2023, that Savarkar had written in a book that he and his friends had assaulted a Muslim man and felt pleasure while doing so.

On the court’s directions, Pune City Police conducted an inquiry and submitted a report on May 27, 2024, stating that Gandhi had defamed Savarkar in his London speech.

The case is being heard by a special MP/MLA court in Pune. Satyaki has been cross-examined over several hearings in 2026, during which he has defended Savarkar’s writings and argued that Savarkar did not harbour hatred towards Muslims and instead wrote about their progress.

The proceedings remain ongoing, and no final verdict has been delivered.

For now, the book remains in circulation, with no court order for a ban or for deletion of passages.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

The Kanpur Cauldron: From the 1931 Conflagration to the Violence of 1992

A historical account of communal disturbances in Kanpur, from...

SP, JMM Accuse BJP of Spreading Confusion Over Pew Report on Religious Population Projections

NEW DELHI -- Reacting to a Pew Research Center...

On Indira Gandhi’s Birth Anniversary, Sonia Shares Personal Memories, Priyanka Hails Her Courage

NEW DELHI -- On the 109th birth anniversary of...

SC Dismisses ED’s Appeal Against Bail to Azam Khan in Money-Laundering Case

The top court clarifies that the Allahabad High Court's...