A historical account of communal disturbances in Kanpur, from British India to the post-Babri Masjid demolition violence
KANPUR, historically known as Cawnpore, emerged as one of northern India’s most important industrial centres during British rule. The expansion of textile mills, leather industries and commercial establishments attracted thousands of workers and traders from Awadh, Bundelkhand and neighbouring regions. Rapid urbanisation, migration and economic competition transformed the city’s social structure. Several interconnected factors contributed to its vulnerability to communal disturbances:
• Industrialisation and economic power: Competition over employment, trade, markets and traditional occupations sometimes acquired a communal dimension. Overcrowded working-class settlements, insecure livelihoods and poor civic facilities further aggravated social tensions.
• Religious mobilisation: The growth of Hindu revivalist and Muslim community organisations, including cow protection and reconversion movements and the Muslim Tanzeem movement, contributed to increasing polarisation during the early 20th century.
• Religious processions and public spaces: Disputes over procession routes, music near mosques, religious flags and the use of public roads repeatedly became flashpoints in mixed-population neighbourhoods.
• Colonial administration: Inadequate preventive policing, delayed intervention and inconsistent enforcement of public-order restrictions sometimes allowed local confrontations to escalate.
• Urban conditions and organised violence: Poverty, overcrowding, neighbourhood tensions and the mobilisation of criminal elements for intimidation, looting and arson added to the city’s vulnerability.
These factors did not operate uniformly in every riot. Their relative importance varied according to the political and social circumstances of each incident. Kanpur’s history demonstrates that religious differences alone cannot explain the recurrence of communal violence; economic competition, political mobilisation and administrative failures also require examination.
Communal Disturbances During British Rule
Kanpur witnessed significant Hindu-Muslim tensions and communal violence well before Independence.
• 1913: A major confrontation arose over a mosque-related dispute, involving the routing of a road through part of a mosque. The incident became an important episode in the history of communal relations in the city.
• 1927: Further communal violence erupted, resulting in deaths and injuries. Contemporary historical accounts also raised questions about the administration’s response.
• March 1931: Kanpur experienced one of the most devastating communal riots of colonial India, involving widespread killings, arson, looting and destruction of religious places and residential properties.
The 1931 disturbances deserve particular attention because they led to separate investigations by the colonial administration and the Indian National Congress.
The 1931 Riots: A Landmark Congress Inquiry
On 24 March 1931, a hartal was called in Kanpur following the execution of Bhagat Singh, Rajguru and Sukhdev on 23 March. Disagreements over the closure of shops, particularly around Meston Road, escalated into communal violence.
The disturbances spread across the city. Temples and mosques were attacked or desecrated, houses were burnt and looted and members of both communities lost their lives.
One of the most tragic casualties was Ganesh Shankar Vidyarthi, the prominent freedom fighter, journalist and nationalist leader. He lost his life on 25 March while attempting to rescue people caught in the violence, irrespective of their religious identity.
The death toll: The Commission of Inquiry estimated that the actual figure could have been between 400 and 500. The Congress inquiry also reported extensive destruction of property and religious buildings.
At its Karachi session in March 1931, the Indian National Congress decided to appoint a committee to investigate the causes of the Kanpur riots, examine the deterioration of Hindu-Muslim relations and recommend measures to prevent similar occurrences.
The six-member committee was headed by Bhagwan Das, with Sundarlal as secretary. The other members included Purushottam Das Tandon, Abdul Latif Bijnori, Manzar Ali Sokhta and Zafarul-Mulk.
Its report went beyond recording the immediate incidents. It examined the historical development of Hindu-Muslim relations, the growth of communal distrust and the political and social circumstances responsible for the deterioration of relations between the two communities. It also challenged historical misconceptions and emphasised India’s shared cultural and social inheritance.
The Congress Working Committee considered the report on 29 December 1931. The report was subsequently proscribed by the colonial government.
Republication by the National Book Trust
More than seven decades later, during the UPA I government, the National Book Trust (NBT) republished the report in 2005 under the title The Communal Problem, bringing this important historical document back into public circulation. Its republication renewed attention to a document that examined communal polarisation, historical misconceptions and the possibilities of Hindu-Muslim reconciliation. It remains relevant to contemporary discussions on communal harmony.
December 1992 Violence
The demolition of Babri Masjid on 6 December 1992 was followed by communal disturbances across several parts of India. Kanpur was among the cities severely affected. The violence spread across different localities, including industrial and predominantly Muslim residential areas. Killings, arson and destruction of property continued over several days. The sequence included:
• 7 December: Communal violence spread across industrial and other parts of Kanpur.
• 8 December onwards: The situation deteriorated, with attacks reported in several localities.
• 10 December: One of the most notorious incidents occurred in Govind Nagar, where a mob attacked Muslim households.
The Govind Nagar Killings
According to police records cited in contemporary newspaper reporting, a mob of approximately 1,000 people raided Muslim houses in Govind Nagar, looted and set them on fire, killing 11 members of different families. The victims included two women and a two-year-old child. The brutality of this incident was subsequently established through criminal proceedings, resulting in the conviction of 15 persons.
How many people were killed in Kanpur? The reported death toll varies according to the source and the geographical and temporal scope of the figures. One contemporary Hindustan Times report, citing police records, placed the number of deaths at 254 over approximately five days of violence, involving victims from both communities.
However, there is no reliable official religion-wise breakdown establishing the total number of Muslim and Hindu victims separately. The figure of 254 should therefore be treated as an attributed reported figure rather than an independently verified community-wise count.
The 11 victims of the Govind Nagar incident, on the other hand, were specifically identified as members of the Muslim community.
The Justice Mathur Commission
Following the 1992 violence, the Uttar Pradesh Government appointed the Justice Mathur Commission of Inquiry to investigate the Kanpur riots. The commission reportedly conducted its inquiry over approximately six years and submitted its report to the State Home Department in 1998.
According to advocate Sharfuddin Ahmed, who represented several riot-affected families, the report reportedly indicted several IAS and IPS officers and public representatives. However, the report was not made fully public and, according to the accounts cited, was not placed before the State Legislative Assembly.
Lawyers and representatives assisting affected families expressed concern that the Mathur Commission’s report did not receive the public attention accorded to other major riot inquiry reports, including the Shri Krishna Commission report on the Mumbai riots.
The continued absence of public access to the Mathur Commission’s findings raises questions about administrative accountability and the treatment of victims’ complaints.
The Victims’ Struggle for Justice: Personal Accounts
Official figures and inquiry reports cannot adequately convey the suffering of individual families. Several accounts reported by the press illustrate the human consequences of the violence.
Shahnaz Hussain survived an attack by hiding behind a sheet. Her husband and 13-year-old son were burnt alive before her eyes. Holding her daughter, she fled on her blistered feet until she collapsed on a highway near a police station.
She spent the next two days trying to persuade the police that her husband and son had been killed. On the third day, she was reportedly made to return home and search through the ashes for human remains. She eventually received compensation of ₹4 lakh but continued to seek justice. Her reported account of the police response was particularly distressing: “They didn’t register the FIR. They told me I had got the money; what would I do pursuing a case as a widow?
Allegations of Organised Attacks
Eyewitness accounts suggested that several attacks were not spontaneous. Houses were reportedly marked and groups of attackers moved with voter lists to identify Muslim households.
Meraj Ali recalled seeing Maruti vans distributing fuel to the rioters, allegedly to facilitate arson attacks. These accounts raise serious questions about the degree of planning involved in the violence and the failure of the administration to prevent attacks.
Shahnaz Hussain reportedly appeared before the commission and produced another witness, Ashok Kumar Pankaj, a bank employee residing in the neighbourhood. In his affidavit, Pankaj alleged that he had seen the District Magistrate and Senior Superintendent of Police arriving with a substantial police contingent. He further stated that he informed them that two men were about to be burnt alive, but they told him to mind his own business.
These allegations, if considered alongside the other evidence submitted to the commission, raise serious questions about the conduct of the local administration and police.
Jamil Khan’s Family
Furniture dealer Jamil Khan reportedly fled with his family, leaving his elderly mother with neighbours. When he returned a week later, his house in New Labour Colony had been burnt and looted. All that remained was a burnt metal trunk. His sister’s wedding took place a few days after the riots. Having lost her clothes and belongings in the attack, she had no alternative but to wear the same clothes she had been wearing when the attackers arrived. The wedding photographs reportedly continued to reflect the tragedy that had overtaken the family.
Religion-wise Muslim count specifically for Kanpur: No official UP Gazette gives a Muslim-only count. Hindustan Times report says victims were from a “predominantly Muslim area” and “11 of the community” were killed in Govind Nagar.
Case files: Chargesheets filed in only 18 of 4,700 cases, rest dropped by Mulayam Singh Yadav govt order dated 23 December 1994 (A copy of the order is with Hindustan Times)
The 2007 judgment: Conviction of 15 persons for the Govind Nagar killings. One significant development in the long struggle for justice came on 24 October 2007. Additional District and Sessions Judge S M Haseeb convicted 15 persons for their involvement in the killing of 11 Muslims in Govind Nagar on 10 December 1992 and sentenced them to life imprisonment.
The trial had continued for approximately 15 years. Several public witnesses turned hostile, while police witnesses provided evidence identifying the accused. The judge criticised the defective investigation but observed that shortcomings in the investigation could not, by themselves, justify allowing guilty persons to escape punishment. He emphasised the responsibility of trial courts to examine available evidence carefully and establish the facts. This judgment was an important instance of criminal accountability in the aftermath of the 1992 violence.
Conclusion
The history of communal violence in Kanpur is not merely a chronology of riots and casualties. It is also a record of recurring failures to address social tensions, protect vulnerable communities, ensure impartial policing and deliver timely justice.
The 1931 Congress inquiry attempted to understand the deeper roots of communal polarisation and offered a wider perspective on India’s shared social and cultural inheritance. The 1992 violence, and the subsequent struggle of victims for justice, demonstrate how unresolved communal tensions and administrative failures can leave lasting scars across generations.
The central lesson from both episodes remains the importance of constitutional values, communal harmony, accountable administration and equal protection of every citizen, irrespective of religion.
_______________

Najmuddin A Farooqi is a Lucknow-based journalist and writer. His areas of interest are social, economic, education and health. The views expressed here are the author’s own and Clarion India does not necessarily subscribe to them.

