SC Dismisses ED’s Appeal Against Bail to Azam Khan in Money-Laundering Case

Date:

The top court clarifies that the Allahabad High Court’s observations were preliminary and should not influence the final adjudication of the case

NEW DELHI — The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld the interim bail granted to Samajwadi Party leader Azam Khan in a money-laundering case linked to alleged financial irregularities concerning the Mohammad Ali Jauhar University.

A Bench of Justices M M Sundresh and P B Varale dismissed the appeal filed by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) against the interim bail granted to Khan by the Allahabad High Court on November 17.

“This being an interim order we are not inclined to interfere. The views of the High Court being prima facie may not have a bearing while deciding the matter finally,” the apex court said in its order.

The top court clarified that the High Court’s observations were preliminary and should not influence the final adjudication of the case.

ED’s Argument, Court’s Response

Additional Solicitor General S V Raju, appearing for the ED, argued that the High Court had wrongly recorded the facts concerning the supply of grounds of arrest to Khan.

“We have given grounds of arrest; he refuses. There’s a video. There’s a panchnama. Facts are wrongly recorded,” Raju said.

The ED maintained that its officers had attempted to hand over the written grounds of arrest to Khan outside the jail, but he had refused to accept the documents.

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal represented Khan before the Supreme Court.

The apex court said it would not interfere with an order granting interim bail, nor attribute motives to the High Court.

“We appreciate it. But its interim bail. We can say while deciding (regular) bail, this observation may not be taken into consideration,” the top court remarked.

“But bail will be dealt by the same bench (of the High Court),” Raju insisted.

“We can’t attribute motive to the (High) Court,” the Supreme Court said while dismissing the plea.

The order leaves the interim bail in place for now, but does not amount to a final determination of the allegations or the legality of the ED’s case.

A Day Earlier: No Stay

The ED had moved the Supreme Court on Wednesday, a day after the High Court order. A Bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant, along with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, had declined to stay the interim bail order at that stage.

The Bench had remarked that “heavens are not going to fall” and listed the matter for hearing on Thursday.

Khan walked out of Dasna district jail in Ghaziabad on Wednesday evening, after completing bail formalities.

His release came on furnishing two bonds of Rs 50,000 each, his counsel said. He was received outside the prison gates by his son Abdullah Azam and later left for his hometown Rampur.

Speaking to reporters outside the prison, Khan said: “I have only one thing to say, the same thing I have always said. A temple of education was built by a Muslim, and this is the punishment for that.”

Later, talking to IANS, the veteran SP leader said: “They (BJP) troubled a person whose record is spotless. I built a temple of education, but because of being a Muslim, the governments caused massive damage to that temple of education as well. Whatever the governments did was wrong.”

Why HC Granted Interim Bail

Khan was granted interim bail by the High Court on November 17. A Bench of Justices Rajiv Gupta and Devendra Singh said Khan’s arrest at the jail gate itself after his release in another case clearly underlined the “motivated and mala fide nature” of the ED proceedings.

The High Court also found that the grounds of arrest and reasons to believe Khan’s involvement in the alleged offences were not furnished to him in writing before or at any time before he was produced for remand.

Khan had challenged his arrest on the ground that it violated Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 19(1) of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA). His legal team argued that the written grounds of arrest were not furnished before he was produced before a special court in Ghaziabad for remand on November 1.

Sequence of Events

Khan and his son Abdullah Azam were earlier in jail in a dual PAN card case. Khan was granted bail by the Allahabad High Court in that case on October 29. As soon as Azam Khan came out of jail on October 31, the ED took him into custody.

The High Court noted that Khan had been taken into custody in the money-laundering case moments after he was physically released from Rampur district jail in another matter, and said the sequence of events raised questions about the circumstances of the arrest.

A special PMLA court in Ghaziabad remanded Khan to judicial custody on November 1. He was granted interim bail on November 17 by the High Court during the pendency of his plea challenging the arrest.

The Underlying Case

The ED action came in relation to the money-laundering case involving alleged financial irregularities concerning the Mohammad Ali Jauhar University. The case involves allegations that agricultural land belonging to farmers was forcibly occupied by the university.

The investigation is linked to the Maulana Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust, which was founded and is controlled by Khan. The ED’s probe concerns allegations of diversion of government funds, irregularities in land acquisition and the construction of the university, where Khan serves as honorary chancellor.

The ED’s money-laundering proceedings against Khan and others were based on around 26 first information reports (FIRs) registered by the Uttar Pradesh Police in 2019.

The ED has alleged that funds and material meant for public works were diverted to the university, that government works were executed on its private campus, and that funds from contractors who had been allotted government contracts were routed back to the Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust as donations.

The High Court will now hear the plea for regular bail.

The Allahabad High Court has directed the ED to file a detailed counter-affidavit in the matter, giving the agency a week to respond. Khan has been allowed 10 days to file his rejoinder, with the next hearing scheduled for December 10.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Fracture, Expel, Humiliate

A little-touted UN report points to Israel’s crimes against...

The March of the Houthis – Saudi Arabia’s Coalition Collapses

Binoy KampmarkYEMEN, land of so much suffering, is becoming...

Jamaat Official Questions Suspension of Life Terms of Bilkis Bano Rape Convicts

Jamaat-e-Islami Hind (JIH) National Secretary Rahamathunnisa A said it...

Did Rahul Tarnish India’s Image Abroad? No, NDA Leaders’ Criticism Is Unfounded

Branding dissent as defamation does not protect India’s image;...