Can Modi Win “Sabka Vishwas”? Did Modi Implement Sabka Sath Sabka Vikas?


Prime Minister Narendra Modi addressing an election rally in Madhya Pradesh on Nov. 25, 2018.


AFTER 2014 victory Modi, Prime Minister of India had promised that he will implement Sabka Sath, Sabka Vikas (Taking everybody along, development for all). To this slogan, he has now added Sabka Vishwas (Every body’s Trust) Many prominent writers and activists from Muslim community, in particular, are trying to reassure themselves that he will keep his promise and not intimidate or oppress religious minorities, Muslims and Christians.

It’s always good to be optimistic and keep the hope alive, but the nagging experience in the recent past of Sabka Vikas raises many questions. The ideology of Hindu nationalism to which Modi belongs also gives rise to the doubts about such a promise. The goal of Hindu Rashtra, the agenda of Hindu right pursued by Modi further dampens the chances of hopeful vision of inclusive peaceful India.

During the last five years of the Modi regime what was witnessed was the increasing sense of insecurity among the minorities. On the top of divisive campaigns like Ram Temple, Ghar Wapasi and love jihad was added the issue of ‘holy cow’-beef eating which took the identity-related hysteria to the sky. This brought to the forefront the phenomenon of the lynching of Muslims and beatings of Dalits. The atrocities heaped on these two communities, in particular, were frightening.

What is called ‘fringe laments’, which are the core part of ‘division of labor’ of Hindu nationalist politics, became more aggressive during this period. Those in power not only turned a blind eye to doings of these aggressive elements but also gave the hints of appreciation of these cruel acts done by saffron-robed, ‘Jai Shri Ram’ chanting crowds. These elements were given the signals, that with this government in power, such acts are a new normal.

The example of Mahesh Sharma, the Union minister draping the body of lynching accused with the tricolor and Jayant Sinha another minister honoring the lynching accused, which got bail, were the permanent approval certificates to those who were to indulge in such barbarian acts. These acts intimidated and marginalized the Muslims to no end. While not to this horrible extent, even Christians had their own share of the woes, as their prayer meetings and Carol singing teams were attacked in the name of ‘attempts for conversion’.

With this background of ‘Sabka Saath Sabka Vikas’, Mr. Modi has now come to power with increased vote share and more seats for BJP. The cause of this massive mandate are being debated, the failure of the opposition to unite, the ultra-nationalism created around the Pulwama attack and the role of EVM machines with partisan election commission are disturbing enough. Meanwhile what is being witnessed in the society during the last few days of Modi-BJP victory is frightening enough.

Right during this little time space we painfully witnessed:

  • In Begusarai, Bihar a Muslim youth Mohammad Qasim was shot at on Sunday (May 26).  Previous morning he was asked his name.
  • Four unidentified youths assaulted a Muslim youth wearing traditional skull cap on May 26.
  • An Adivasi professor was arrested over a Facebook post (May 25). In the post, he had mentioned the right to eat beef.
  • In Raipur, Chhattisgarh, a group of self-styled gau rakshaks entered a dairy (May 26) and accused people in the shop of cow slaughter and the sale of beef. They vandalized the shop and assaulted them..
  • In Mahuvad, Vadodara, village (Gujarat), a house of the Dalit couple was allegedly attacked by a mob of 200-300 upper caste people. His crime was that the husband had put up a Facebook post saying that the government does not permit the village temple to be used for Dalit wedding ceremonies.
  • As per Janata Ka Reporter in Assam a Muslim man, Ashraf Ali, believed to be in his early 90s, ended his life. He was fearful of the possibility of his being declared a foreigner and being sent to the detention centre.  The victim’s body was found from a school campus, close to his hut in Sontoli in Boko, 70 kms west of Guwahati,

So many incidents in such a short duration of time just indicate as to how the atmosphere is being vitiated due to Modi coming to power again. On one hand, the so-called fringe is emboldened more than before and this is the signal of their unrestrained behavior. On the other, the people do know the portents of the policies which Modi pursued during the last five years and may be pursued with intense vigor now. The BJP President called the Muslim refugees as termites. That in a way sums up what Muslims mean to the ruling dispensation.

Interestingly of the 303 MPs elected on the BJP ticket not a single one is from the Muslim community. The overall representation of Muslims in Lok Sabha has come down and remains so. The Muslim community has weathered many a storm in the past. Its reflection came in the Rangnath Mishra and Sachar commission reports. While the Congress and other semi secular parties have been blamed for Muslim appeasement, the socio-economic and political conditions of the Muslim community have worsened over a period of time. Many committed leaders from the Muslim community are feeling totally left out in the democratic processes, which anyway are being undermined more so from the last decade or so.

The core reason for violence being witnessed is the frightening rise of Hindu nationalist politics, the Hindutva. Earlier RSS gave rise to different progenies, what they call collectively as Sangh Parivar. Now with the trappings of power, BJP being in majority in Center, the major expansion of RSS shakhas has taken place, which is further strengthening different offshoots of this organization.

One understands that the security of minorities is the reflection of strength of democracy. On that count also the index of democratic values in our country is something to be worried about!


Ram Puniyani is an eminent author, activist and former professor of IIT Mumbai. The views are personal and Caravan Daily does not necessarily share or subscribe to them.

Clarion India - News, Views and Insights about Indian Muslims, Dalits, Minorities, Women and Other Marginalised and Dispossessed Communities.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:




More like this

Israel Wants Temporary Ceasefire Agreement in Gaza: Hamas Official

GAZA—Israel is seeking a ceasefire agreement with Hamas to...

Constitutional Institutions Not Personal Property of PM Modi, Says Rahul Gandhi

Let me make it very clear, the Congress party...

CM Kejriwal TO Hold Review Meeting With Ministers From Next Week, Govt Will Run From Jail: AAP

From next week, the chief minister will call two...