NEW DELHI — The Supreme Court has suspended the life sentences of two men convicted in the Bilkis Bano gang rape and murder case and granted them bail, noting that they have already spent more than 17 years behind bars. The decision has drawn severe criticism with people raising concerns over the impact of the decision on Bilkis Bano and her family.
AIMIM national spokesperson Waris Pathan criticised the Supreme Court’s decision, pointing to a disparity between the relief granted to the convicts and the prolonged incarceration of innocent, guiltless undertrial prisoners who, he said, continue to remain in jail for years without bail or even the commencement of their trials.
Reacting to the development, Pathan said those who deserved the death penalty had been granted bail, while several innocent undertrial prisoners were still waiting for relief despite spending years behind bars.
“Those who should have received the death penalty have been granted bail, while innocent, guiltless youths trapped inside the courts—whose verdicts haven’t been delivered yet, who aren’t getting bail for six years, whose trials haven’t even begun—are locked up inside jails,” Pathan said while speaking to the news agency IANS.
Expressing anger over the brutality of the crime, he further said, “Hey, these are the monsters who wiped out Bilkis Bano’s entire family, grabbed little children and smashed their heads with stones, killed them, committed rape; these are the kind of monsters who shouldn’t be left outside even for a single minute.”
Journalist Vedika Sud also questioned the repeated legal developments in the case and their impact on Bilkis Bano, asking how many times the survivor would be forced to relive the trauma.
In a post on X, Sud wrote, “How many times must Bilkis Bano be forced to relive her trauma? First, the remission of 11 convicts. Then their return to prison after the Supreme Court overturned that release. Now, two are out on bail again.”
Emphasising that the legal process should not overshadow the survivor’s experience, she added, “The law must take its course. But spare a thought for Bilkis Bano. Justice is a legal process. Trauma is a lifetime.”
https://x.com/vedikas/status/2122313637624975694?a=kA-iQ4Q4EJCEchn3DBQ&s=20
Journalist Vasundhara Sirnate also expressed strong reservations about the Supreme Court’s decision, arguing that the gravity of the crime and the trauma suffered by Bilkis Bano should remain central to any discussion surrounding the convicts’ release.
Recalling that Bilkis Bano was five months pregnant when she was gang-raped while fleeing the 2002 communal violence in Gujarat, Sirnate pointed out that several members of her family, including her three-year-old daughter and other children, were killed.
“I do think the Indian Supreme Court has erred in this ruling,” she wrote, questioning what justice means for a survivor who has endured such a horrific crime and whether she can ever feel safe knowing that those convicted in the case may eventually return to society.
https://x.com/vsirnate/status/2122299466178761012?a=481QH_-bHX5-YvntGeo&s=20
Sirnate further questioned the message such developments could send to survivors of sexual violence and those considering seeking justice.
“How safe do you think she feels knowing the perpetrators are going to get out eventually? Can you imagine the kind of bravery it took on her part to seek justice from the state and come out and be known publicly as a survivor?” she wrote.
Acknowledging the court’s observation regarding the disability of one of the appellants, Sirnate said she could not overlook the severity of the crimes committed against Bilkis Bano.
“I understand that one of the perpetrators is disabled now and perhaps some empathy towards him has been summoned by the Court. I cannot overlook the extent and severity of the crimes that were committed against Bilkis Bano in 2002,” she added.
The two convicts, Bipin Chandra Joshi and Pradeep Mordhiya, were granted relief by a bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale. In an order dated October 28, released on Monday, the bench took note of the fact that both men had spent more than 17 years in prison. It also considered that one of the appellants suffers from a severe physical disability.
“… also the fact remains that one of the appellants has a severe handicap,” the bench observed.
The court acknowledged that several issues in the appeals were yet to be decided but said the circumstances warranted suspension of their sentences while the legal proceedings continued.
“Certainly, there are issues to be decided… (but) in view of the above and considering issues involved in this appeal, we suspend the sentence and grant bail to the appellants on such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the trial court,” the order stated.
Joshi and Mordhiya had approached the Supreme Court challenging a Bombay High Court judgment that upheld their convictions and life sentences.
During the hearing, senior advocate Siddharth Luthra, appearing for the appellants, reportedly argued that one of the men had not been named in the original FIR and was implicated nearly three years after the crime. The defence also questioned the evidence against the two, arguing that no specific role had been attributed to them in the gang rape and torture of Bilkis Bano and that the evidence primarily pointed to their possible presence at the scene.
Opposing their plea, Additional Solicitor General Raja Thakre argued that the trial court and the Gujarat High Court had already considered the relevant evidence and material. He also highlighted the seriousness of the offences committed by the two men.
Supreme Court had earlier quashed remission granted to 11 convicts
Joshi and Mordhiya were among the 11 men convicted in the case who were released from prison in August 2022 after the Gujarat government granted them remission.
Their release triggered widespread criticism and was challenged by Bilkis Bano before the Supreme Court.
In January 2024, the Supreme Court quashed the remission granted to all 11 convicts, holding that the Gujarat government was not the appropriate authority to decide their applications.
In a strongly worded judgment, a bench of Justices BV Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan described the state’s decision as “an instance of usurpation of jurisdiction and… of abuse of discretion”.
The court further observed that the Gujarat government had “acted in tandem and was complicit” with the convicts in granting them remission.
It also held that Gujarat was not the “appropriate” government to decide their remission applications, describing the crime as a “grotesque and diabolical crime…driven by communal hatred”.
Bilkis Bano was five months pregnant when she was gang-raped
The case dates back to February 2002, when communal violence erupted in Gujarat following the Godhra train burning incident.
Bilkis Bano was 21 years old and five months pregnant when she was gang-raped while trying to escape the violence with members of her family. Seven members of her family were killed in the attack, including her three-year-old daughter, whose head was smashed against a stone.
In 2008, a special CBI court convicted 11 men for offences including gang rape, murder and rioting. All were sentenced to life imprisonment.
The latest Supreme Court order suspends the sentences of Joshi and Mordhiya and allows them to remain on bail while their appeals remain pending. It does not overturn their convictions.

