SC Suspends Life Terms of Two Convicts in Bilkis Bano Case, Grants Them Bail

Date:

Joshi and Mordhiya will be released on bail on conditions fixed by the trial court in Mumbai, but the hapless victim’s wounds have never been allowed to fully heal

NEW DELHI — For Bilkis Bano, it is a wound that has never been allowed to fully heal.

Twenty-three years after she was gang-raped while five months pregnant, watched her three-and-a-half-year-old daughter Saleha smashed to death before her eyes, and saw 14 members of her family butchered, the Supreme Court has now suspended the life sentences of two of the men convicted for those crimes and granted them bail.

A bench of Justices M M Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale passed the order on October 28, which was uploaded only on Monday (November 16), The Hindu reported.

The two men are Bipin Chandra Joshi alias Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi alias Lala Doctor, and Pradeep Mordhiya alias Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya.

Both are among the 11 convicts whose premature release by the Gujarat government on August 15, 2022 was quashed by the Supreme Court on January 8, 2024.

The bench said the two appellants had spent more than 17 years in prison, that one of them has a severe handicap, and that their appeals raise questions of fact and law that still need to be decided.

“Having heard the parties, suffice it to state that the appellants have been under incarceration for a period of more than 17 years, and also the fact remains that one of the appellants has a severe handicap. Certainly, there are issues to be decided in the appeal, both on fact and law,” the court said.

“In view of the above and considering the issues involved in this appeal, we suspend the sentence and grant bail to the appellants on such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the concerned trial court.”

Not Acquittal

The suspension of sentence is not an acquittal. Their appeals against conviction are still pending and will be heard separately.

Senior advocate Siddharth Luthra, appearing for the two convicts, told the court they had spent more than 17 years in custody. He submitted that one of the men had not been named in the FIR and was implicated nearly three years after the 2002 riots.

Additional Solicitor General Raja Thakre, appearing for Gujarat, opposed the bail pleas, arguing that the trial court and the Bombay High Court had considered the relevant material, particularly given the seriousness of the offences.

Joshi and Mordhiya were convicted under provisions of the Indian Penal Code relating to unlawful assembly (Section 143), rioting (147), murder (302) read with rape (376), and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for life with fine.

The other nine convicts remain in prison. They are Govind Nai, Ramesh Chandana, Mitesh Bhatt, Bakabhai Vohania, Kesarbhai Vohania, Jaswant Nai, Radheshyam Shah, Rajubhai Soni and Shailesh Bhatt.

Black Day for Bilkis

Bilkis was 19 years old, later described in court records as 21, and five months pregnant when the violence reached her village, Randhikpur in Dahod district, Gujarat, days after the Godhra train burning on February 27, 2002.

She had gone to her mother’s home for Eid. As mobs set fire to Muslim homes in the village, she fled on foot on February 28 with 16 family members — her mother, sisters, brothers, her little daughter Saleha, her maternal uncle, her paternal aunt and others.

For two days they hid in a mosque, in Adivasi homes, and in fields. Her aunt’s daughter gave birth to a baby girl in hiding.

On March 3, as they walked on a kutcha road near Chhaparwad, between two hills, two vehicles carrying 30-40 men armed with swords, spears, scythes, sticks, daggers and bows and arrows surrounded them.

In her own words, recorded on March 22, 2002 at the Godhra Relief Camp, Bilkis said:

“They started screaming, ‘Kill them, Cut them up!’ They raped my two sisters and me and behaved in an inhuman way with my uncle and aunt’s daughters. They tore our clothes and raped eight of us. Before my very eyes they killed my 3½-year-old daughter.”

She named men she knew from her own village — Shailesh Bhatt, Lala Doctor, Lala Vakil and Govind Navi among them — as those who raped her.

“After raping me, they beat me up. Having been injured in the head, I fainted. They left, assuming I was dead.”

When she regained consciousness two to three hours later, she found herself surrounded by corpses. Her mother, her sisters, her aunt, her cousins — including a two-day-old baby whose mother, Shamim, had just given birth — were dead. She climbed a hill, spent the night there alone, naked and bleeding, and came down the next morning to find a police team collecting bodies.

An Adivasi woman gave her a blouse and an odhani to cover herself. She was taken to Limkheda police station.

She was the sole survivor and the sole eyewitness.

Long, Strenuous Fight for Justice

What followed, Bilkis has said repeatedly, was a second agony — the agony of seeking justice.

Her complaint was not recorded as she narrated it. The local police filed a closure report — an ‘A Summary’ — claiming no evidence. A local court accepted it.

It was only after the National Human Rights Commission gave her legal aid and she approached the Supreme Court that the closure was set aside, the investigation was handed to the CBI, and the trial was transferred out of Gujarat to Mumbai.

In 2008, a special CBI court convicted 12 persons. It held that Jaswantbhai Nai, Govindbhai Nai and Naresh Kumar Mordhiya (now deceased) had raped Bilkis, while Shailesh Bhatt had killed Saleha by smashing her on the ground.

In May 2017, the Bombay High Court upheld the conviction and life sentences of 11 men, calling Bilkis’s testimony consistent and truthful despite the passage of time and trauma.

For Bilkis, who had lived in hiding, moved homes repeatedly, and raised her children in fear, that verdict was the first moment she said she could “breathe again.”

The Remission Shock

That fragile peace was shattered on August 15, 2022, when the Gujarat government released all 11 convicts under its remission policy. They were garlanded and welcomed with sweets outside Godavara jail.

Bilkis said at the time she felt numb, that her faith in justice had been shaken, and that she could not understand how men convicted of such brutality could be freed on Independence Day.

She challenged the remission in the Supreme Court. On January 8, 2024, a bench of Justices B V Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan quashed the remission, holding that Gujarat had “usurped” the power of Maharashtra — where the trial had taken place — and had been “complicit” with the convicts. The court ordered all 11 to return to prison within two weeks.

That judgment was seen as a landmark vindication for Bilkis.

Monday’s order reopens that pain — not by freeing the two men finally, but by letting them walk out on bail while their appeals drag on, after 17 years behind bars.

Joshi and Mordhiya will be released on bail on conditions fixed by the trial court in Mumbai. Their appeals challenging conviction and life sentence remain pending before the Supreme Court and the other nine convicts remain in jail.

For Bilkis Bano, the woman who once told an interviewer, haltingly, through tears that did not stop, “I have filed a complaint with the police but I don’t know whether I will get justice” — the question remains the same, 23 years later: how long must a survivor keep reliving March 3, 2002, every time a court door opens for her attackers?

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Haryana: Two Muslim ‘Cattle Smugglers’ Slain, Another Injured in Alleged Police Encounter

NUH/NEW DELHI — Two Muslims suspected of cattle smuggling...

SIO, APCR Activists Held in Hyderabad Ahead of T-Hub Event with Israeli Firms

HYDERABAD — Police in Hyderabad detained members of the...

Australia, Canada, Italy and the UK Urge Israel to Allow Aid Into Gaza

The countries accuse Israel of preventing tents and other...

Trump’s Defeat and Modi’s Challenge: Can a Global Leftward Shift Reach India?

THE sun may be setting on the Musk-Epstein-Trump class,...