Noam Chomsky, Harsh Mander, Other Intellectuals Term Modi Govt Treatment of Muslims ‘Horrific, Lethal’


Prime Minister Narendra Modi


Press Release

WASHINGTON, DC – The treatment of Indian Muslims under Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been “lethal,” “horrific,” and a threat to democratic values, Prof Noam Chomsky and other globally renowned intellectuals and activists said at a Congressional Briefing on Wednesday, February 9.

“Islamophobia is taking its most lethal form in India, where the Modi government is systematically dismantling Indian secular democracy and turning the country into a Hindu ethnocracy, with almost 250 million Muslims becoming a persecuted minority,” said Prof Noam Chomsky, one of the world’s leading public intellectuals and Professor Emeritus at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

“The assault is taking other forms as well, including a general attack on independent thought and the educational system primarily directed against Muslim victims, but by now expanding beyond.”

Harsh Mander, a prominent Indian activist now based in Berlin, Germany, and nominated last week for the Nobel Peace Prize, said India’s “immense tragedy” was that people “steeped deeply in the Hindu supremacist ideology that spurred Gandhi’s killing are in fact ruling India today. India’s leaders are more determined than ever to push the country down this horrific path of hate, fear and blood.”

Mander, who was nominated for the Nobel Prize for his work on the Karwan-E-Mohabbat programme that helps provide support to the families of mob lynching victims, said India was witnessing early signs of an impending genocide.

“It is tempting for supporters of the ruling establishment to dismiss claims of possible genocide as alarmist… and ‘foreign’ interference, and not efforts ‘to alert the national conscience,’” Mander said. “But the Holocaust Memorial Museum Report warns of the dangers of such denial. ‘We know from the Holocaust what can happen when early warning signs go unheeded.’”

Mander pointed out the vast number of ways India’s general public had become desensitised to Hindu supremacist ideals.

“Online and in public gatherings, a range of other extreme right-wing supporters… are even more candid in spouting their hate, openly calling for boycotts and expulsions, mass killing, genocide and mass rape. Sometimes for the record a thin official line is drawn, claiming official distance from these ‘fringe’ elements. But this claim wears thin because hatemongers are rarely punished, get bail quickly if at all they are arrested, many are instead inducted into party positions.”

Also speaking at the Congressional Briefing, which was organised by a coalition of 17 human rights organisations, John Sifton, Washington, D.C.-based Asia Advocacy Director of Human Rights Watch, said the “greatest threat” to India’s Constitution today was the government’s “promotion of India’s majority religion, Hinduism, at the expense of the country’s secular foundation and its religious minorities. Worse still, there are growing concerns over the independence of Indian institutions. The Election Commission, the judiciary, and the National Human Rights Commission are all facing increasing scrutiny under implications of bias.”

Emphasising the need for global efforts in order for the Indian government to take heed, Sifton added, “These deteriorations are threatening India’s underlying identity — the very idea of India as a diverse, pluralistic nation state — and they harm India’s global standing as a functioning, rights-respecting democracy. In every opportunity that presents itself, US officials, citizens, members of Congress, should forcefully communicate concerns about these deteriorations to the Indian government.”

Speaking on the increased mobilisation of Hindutva extremists in view of assembly elections in India, Angana Chatterji, a scholar at University of California at Berkeley and a co-founder of the International People’s Tribunal on Human Rights and Justice in Kashmir said: “At the onset of critical state-level elections in India, Hindu nationalist leaders are energising their constituents with calls for massified violence against Muslims and promises to deliver on hate.” Minority communities and allies are urgently concerned that, should a BJP victory fail to materialize in state elections, aggravated antipathy to Muslims will inspire Hindu nationalists to take up arms.”

Even as hate speech increases, press freedoms and the right to freedom of expression have been repressed by the government, she added.

“Journalists have been exposed to all kinds of dangers – police violence, reprisals instigated by local officials/ministers, illegal detentions, slapping them with sedition and so on,” said Annapurna Menon, a doctoral researcher and visiting lecturer at the University of Westminster. “[Because] India’s ranking has slipped to 142 on the [the World Press Freedom] Index, the situation on ground is extremely alarming.”

The briefing was co-hosted by 17 organisations, including Amnesty International USA, Genocide Watch, 21Wilberforce, Hindus for Human Rights, Indian American Muslim Council, International Christian Concern, Jubilee Campaign, Dalit Solidarity Forum, New York State Council of Churches, Federation of Indian American Christian Organizations of North America, India Civil Watch International, Students Against Hindutva Ideology, Center for Pluralism, American Muslim Institution, International Society for Peace and Justice, Association of Indian Muslims of America, and the Humanism Project (Australia).


Clarion India - News, Views and Insights about Indian Muslims, Dalits, Minorities, Women and Other Marginalised and Dispossessed Communities.

Share post:


More like this

Congress’ Danish Ali, Gogoi Demolish Assam CM’s Claim on Surge in Muslim Population

Assam will become a Muslim-majority state by 2041 and...

‘Conspiracy to Kill Him in Jail’: AAP Accuses BJP of Messing with Kejriwal’s Health

Addressing a press conference, Sanjay Singh said that Kejriwal's...