Delhi HC to Hear Fresh Plea Against Demolition of Krishi Bhawan Mosque on November 23

Date:

A worshipper has challenged the Centre’s authority to remove Qadeemi Masjid under the Central Vista project, citing a registered 1945 agreement and demanding due process

NEW DELHI — The Delhi High Court will hear on November 23 a petition seeking protection for a more than 100-year-old mosque inside the Krishi Bhawan complex from demolition under the Central Vista redevelopment project. The petition, filed by Mohammed Yasir, argues that the Centre cannot remove the mosque without first establishing its legal right to recover possession of the property and complying with the conditions of a registered agreement dating back to 1945.

Justice Anish Dayal on Friday deferred the hearing on Yasir’s petition after noting that another case concerning the same mosque, known as Qadeemi Masjid or Masjid Krishi Bhawan, was also scheduled to come up before the court next week. The court has now listed both matters for 23 November.

During the hearing, advocate M. Sufian Siddiqui, appearing for Yasir, told the court that the mosque remains functional and faces an imminent threat of demolition. He argued that the Central Government has no authority to demolish the 266-square-yard structure merely because it does not have the status of a protected monument.

The Centre’s counsel opposed the fresh petition, describing it as an attempt to expand the scope of an earlier case. She also told the court that she had not yet received instructions from the concerned authorities.

1945 agreement at the centre of the legal challenge

A key element of Yasir’s petition is a registered agreement executed in 1945 between the then government authorities and Sunni Majlis-e-Aukaf, the predecessor body of the Delhi Waqf Board. The agreement laid down the arrangements governing the mosque’s use and management.

According to the petition, the agreement does not give the government an unrestricted right to take back possession of the premises. It provides for the possibility of the government re-entering the property in the event of a breach or default in the agreement’s conditions.

Siddiqui argued that the government must first establish that a material breach of the agreement has occurred. It would then have to invoke the relevant re-entry provision, lawfully terminate the agreement and recover possession through the prescribed legal process, including appropriate civil proceedings.

The petition maintains that even if the government establishes a right to recover possession, that would not automatically authorise the demolition of the mosque.

It argues that the proposed action cannot be justified solely by citing the requirements of the Central Vista redevelopment project. The government, it says, must demonstrate an independent legal basis for removing the structure and follow the procedure required by law.

Centre says mosque is incompatible with secular character of government property

The latest petition comes amid a separate legal challenge brought by the caretaking committee of Qadeemi Masjid, which approached the High Court in September after expressing apprehension that the mosque could be demolished.

In October, while responding to that earlier petition, the Centre informed the court that it intended to remove the mosque from the Krishi Bhawan premises as part of the redevelopment project. The government argued that retaining a permanent religious structure within a government office complex was impermissible and incompatible with the secular character of government property.

The Centre’s position has become a central issue in the legal dispute. The petitioners, however, argue that the government cannot use the principle of secularism as an independent source of executive authority to remove a religious institution without following the law.

Yasir’s petition contends that secularism is a constitutional obligation on the State, not a justification for extinguishing places of worship simply because they stand on government-controlled land.

The dispute therefore involves questions about the terms of the 1945 agreement, the government’s authority over the premises and the legal procedure required before any action can be taken against the mosque. <Cite refs={[“turn280724view0″,”turn902326search3”]}/>

High Court questions scope for judicial intervention
During Friday’s proceedings, Justice Dayal raised questions about the scope of judicial intervention, particularly in view of the ownership position and the government’s plan to redevelop the wider area.

The court observed that ownership of the property was not in dispute and questioned the basis on which it could intervene when the mosque was not a protected monument and the government was undertaking redevelopment of the surrounding premises.

In response, Siddiqui argued that the government’s ownership or control of the land did not allow it to disregard the conditions of the 1945 agreement. He maintained that any attempt to take back possession would have to comply with the agreement and the applicable legal process.

The court did not decide the merits of the dispute during Friday’s hearing. It deferred the matter to 23 November, when it is expected to consider the two petitions concerning the mosque.

The Delhi Waqf Board is also a party to the proceedings. In the separate petition, the court orally directed the Board to obtain instructions before the next hearing. Yasir’s petition has accused the Board of failing to take adequate steps to discharge its statutory responsibilities towards the mosque. <Cite refs={[“turn902326view0″,”turn280724view0”]}/>

Central Vista redevelopment and the mosque

The legal dispute has emerged against the backdrop of the Central Vista redevelopment project, which involves the construction of new government buildings and the redevelopment of the administrative district in New Delhi.

The Indian Express reported that the Central Public Works Department (CPWD), under the Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, floated a tender on 19 January for the construction of Common Central Secretariat buildings 4 and 5 at the sites of Krishi Bhawan and Shastri Bhawan.

The mosque is situated within the Krishi Bhawan complex, which is part of the area affected by the redevelopment plans. The caretaking committee approached the court after apprehending that the project could lead to the mosque’s removal.

The Centre’s stated position is that the presence of a permanent religious structure is incompatible with the character of a government office complex. The petitioners, on the other hand, argue that redevelopment plans cannot override existing legal obligations or dispense with due process.

The 1945 agreement has consequently become an important part of the challenge to the proposed removal of the mosque. <Cite refs={[“turn280724view0″,”turn902326search4”]}/>

Two petitions to be considered on 23 November

The High Court is now scheduled to hear two petitions relating to Qadeemi Masjid on 23 November. One was filed by the mosque’s caretaking committee, while the fresh petition was brought by Mohammed Yasir, who has described himself as a regular worshipper.

The fresh plea seeks to establish that the government must demonstrate its legal entitlement to recover the premises and comply with the conditions of the 1945 agreement before taking any steps to remove the mosque.

For now, the High Court has not delivered a final ruling on the proposed demolition or the legal claims raised by either side. The next hearing is expected to bring the competing arguments over the mosque’s future and the government’s authority into sharper focus.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Hindutva Men Attack Protesting Junior Doctors in Kolkata Medical College, Injuring Six

Attackers claiming links to BJP-affiliated organisations stormed the campus...

Pew Research Report: Numbers Are Not a Religious Clash

A  NEW Pew Research Center projection says Muslims could...

People Rejected BJP’s Misrule in Panchayati Raj Polls: Rajasthan Congress

JAIPUR —  Following the counting of votes for the...

ICJ Ruling on Myanmar’s Rohingya Genocide Has Alarmed Israel Apologists

Mouin RabbaniON Thursday 19 November 2026 the International Court...