Communalising Cricket? Siraj’s Exclusion from First Test Results in Political Slugfest

Date:

Gavaskar, Shastri, Ashwin, Azharuddin, Wasim Jaffer; veteran commentator Harsha Bhogle and senior journalist Rajdeep Sardesai are among those who have expressed shock at the pacer’s exclusion

BENGALURU — His name is ‘Siraj’, and that is why he was not given a place.”

With that one line, Congress MP Imran Masood on Friday turned a cricket selection call into a full-blown political slugfest, alleging that Indian fast bowler Mohammed Siraj was left out of the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand at Wellington because of his religious identity.

Masood, the Congress MP from Saharanpur, was speaking to the media a day after India opted for a four-pronged pace attack without Siraj at the Basin Reserve, despite the 48-Test veteran being India’s highest wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship cycle.

“It is being said that despite his good performance, he was not given a place in the team. His name is ‘Siraj’, and that is why he was not given a place. If you are not selecting him despite his good performance, the discrimination is clear,” Masood told ANI.

 

BJP Hits Back

The BJP rejected the allegation within hours, accusing the Congress of bringing vote-bank and communal politics into cricket.

BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari responded in a post on X, saying team selection should not be linked to religion. He pointed out that Ravindra Jadeja had also been left out of the playing XI.

“Shame on Congress! Congress now does vote bank politics even in Cricket team selection! Congress says – ‘Siraj was left out because he was a Muslim’. Even Jadeja was left out! Every cricketer wears the jersey representing India! Stop dividing Indian cricket team for vote bank and communal politics!” Bhandari wrote.

BJP spokesperson for Mumbai, Aniket Nikam, went further, saying Masood should stop “spreading poison in society.”

Union Minister Kiren Rijiju also weighed in on Friday, rejecting Masood’s charge and insisting that opportunities in India are given on merit, not on religion or caste.

“Nobody here is discriminated against or overlooked on the basis of their religion. In our country, opportunities are given based on merit. One’s religion or caste has nothing to do with it. If someone feels this way, it is not right,” media reports quoted Rijiju as saying.

Masood’s remarks landed amid already widespread criticism from former cricketers over Siraj’s absence — criticism made purely on cricketing grounds, which gave the political charge added traction.

Former India head coach Ravi Shastri questioned the decision, pointing to the fast bowler’s experience, aggression and ability to make an impact with the ball.

“Hope India bounce back strongly. But if pace, skill and seam movement were the criteria, and 140 clicks was hard to come by, one has to ask the question. Where was MOHD SIRAJ? Experience, aggression and the ability to make things happen with the ball. Surely that counts for something,” Shastri wrote on X.

During the broadcast, former India captain Sunil Gavaskar also questioned the decision, saying Siraj had “never let India down” and was in good rhythm.

“There were signs when he did not join the Test squad early. I thought they were going to play him after he featured in the final ODI,” Gavaskar said on Sony Sports after the toss. “But this is a surprise. I don’t think he has let India down. He has never let India down. There is nothing wrong with his bowling. His rhythm is good. Why he has not been picked is something I don’t know. I only hope the others who have been picked ahead of him deliver.”

Later, as New Zealand fought back, Gavaskar added: “Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna started playing Tests only a year or two ago. On the other hand, Mohammed Siraj, one of your experienced bowlers, was available and you haven’t picked him. For me, to think Siraj is not among your top four bowlers is a little hard to get over.”

Former India captain and Telangana minister Mohammed Azharuddin expressed disappointment over the omission, saying Siraj had shown his commitment and ability, particularly when Jasprit Bumrah was unavailable.

“Disappointed to see Mohammed Siraj missing from the India squad. His performances, especially when Team India needed him in Bumrah’s absence, have shown his commitment, ability and fighting spirit. He has consistently stepped up and delivered for the country. While I wish Kamboj the very best, I believe Siraj deserved better consideration. I hope this decision is explained to him with the clarity and respect he deserves,” Azharuddin wrote on X.

 

Ashwin, Jaffer, Bhogle join chorus

Former India spinner Ravichandran Ashwin called the decision “harsh, very harsh,” and warned on his YouTube channel that a “mahaul” had been created around Siraj’s place for over a month. He claimed this was “just the trailer” and even suggested Siraj could struggle to find a place in India’s 2027 ODI World Cup squad.

Former opener Wasim Jaffer termed the decision “absolutely shocking,” pointing out that Siraj had played a crucial role in levelling the England series and was India’s leading wicket-taker in the ongoing WTC cycle. “India are already missing him,” Jaffer said, as New Zealand recovered on Day 1.

Veteran commentator Harsha Bhogle said he was “flabbergasted” by the exclusion, saying Siraj had consistently delivered for India and stepped up in Bumrah’s absence. He hoped the team management would have honest conversations with the pacer.

Senior journalist Rajdeep Sardesai also questioned leaving out both Siraj and Jadeja, arguing that the bowling attack appeared to lack enough wicket-taking options on the opening day.

Fans on social media echoed the former players, with many calling themselves “flabbergasted and disappointed” at the omission of a bowler with 43 wickets in 11 matches in this WTC cycle at an average of 26.81 and a strike rate of 45.69.

 

Day 1 Added Fuel

The debate intensified after New Zealand, put in to bat by India captain Shubman Gill after winning the toss, recovered from 70 for 5 to finish Day 1 at 243 for 5, with Henry Nicholls unbeaten on 113 and Glenn Phillips on 94.

With Bumrah doing most of the damage, India’s other pace options struggled to make an impact, prompting fresh scrutiny of the decision to leave out Siraj’s experience and ability to break partnerships.

 

Team Management Defends Call

Captain Shubman Gill and the team management have maintained that the best possible XI was picked for the conditions.

Gill said at the toss: “Quite tough, you know. We were contemplating for the past one week which combination to go with because all of our fast bowlers have been doing really well. Very difficult for Siraj and Gurnoor, both of them, to miss out.”

India went in with Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj and Prasidh Krishna as the four pacers, with Washington Sundar as the spin-bowling all-rounder.

India’s assistant coach Sitanshu Kotak had earlier defended the selection, saying the management considered the chosen playing XI best suited to the conditions at the Basin Reserve. He cited the pitch’s grass cover and the need for pace, seam movement, swing and bounce.

“There is nothing wrong with Siraj. We thought this was the best XI when we picked the side. I don’t think dropping Siraj was a wrong decision. This is just the first day. We don’t pick a team only for day one, but also for days two, three and four,” Kotak said on Thursday.

He added that India wanted a combination of bowlers with different skills — two capable of swinging the ball and two who could offer seam movement and pace.

For now, what began as a debate over pace, seam and conditions in Wellington has spilled well beyond the boundary rope — into war rooms of political parties and prime-time debate, with cricket’s oldest fault line, selection, now reframed as a question of identity.

 

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

India’s Religious Make-up: What a New Pew Study says About Hindus and Muslims

Soutik Biswas | BBC  India will remain overwhelmingly Hindu for...

India’s Census 2027 Could Pave Way for Nationwide NRC, Rights Group Warns UN

The South Asia Justice Campaign warns that the proposed...

The Enemy at Home

The belief that Democrats will dismantle a system designed...

What the ICJ Genocide Ruling Means for the Rohingya People

This is the first time the court has ruled...