Muslims Being Targeted in India’s Voter Roll Revisions, Says US Religious Freedom Panel

Date:

India’s voter-list revision removed 130 million names in the largest deletion of voters in the country’s history

WASHINGTON/NEW DELHI — India has escalated its targeting of religious minorities during a voter-list revision that struck off tens of millions of names nationwide, a US panel on religious freedom said on Thursday.

“The Indian government is targeting Muslim citizens by removing them from voter rolls, calling them ‘foreigners,’ and now illegally deporting them,” Asif Mahmood, the chair of the US Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF), said in a statement.

USCIRF also quoted Mahmood as saying the crackdown was unfolding “as (Union) Home Minister Amit Shah has referred to Muslims as ‘infiltrators’ that must be expelled.”

On November 2, Shah had claimed that three crore of the voters removed from the electoral rolls during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) were “Bangladeshi infiltrators.” At a November 5 rally in Haryana, he went further: “It is the BJP’s resolve that we will detect infiltrators, remove them from the electoral rolls, and after that, we will pick them out one by one and expel them from the country,” he said.

Largest Deletion in India’s History

India’s voter-list revision removed 130 million names in the largest deletion of voters in the country’s history.

According to figures shared by the Election Commission of India, about 7.2 crore names were deleted from draft rolls during the first two phases of the SIR, which covered 13 states and Union Territories. In the ongoing third phase, covering 18 states and Union Territories, 6.16 crore names have been removed so far.

The first phase was conducted in Bihar in 2025. It was extended to 12 states and Union Territories in the second phase in late 2025 and the first half of 2026. The third phase, covering 19 states and Union Territories, is underway.

Data shows the omissions disproportionately affect Muslims, India’s largest minority, who have faced what rights groups describe as exclusionary policies and rising discrimination since Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party took power in 2014.

In West Bengal, where the revision has run furthest, around 9 million names were cut ahead of state elections earlier this year. Muslims made up about 70% of the 2.7 million names deleted after a closer review, despite being 27% of the population, according to the Kolkata-based Sabar Institute. The BJP emerged victorious in those polls and took control of the state for the first time.

“We cannot deny the anti-incumbency factor but the voter deletions played a big role in determining West Bengal election results,” the institute’s founder, Sabir Ahamed, said.

From Rolls to Deportation

The revision has become entangled with a separate drive to identify and expel suspected illegal immigrants, even though removal from the rolls does not itself establish that someone is a foreigner.

In May, the Supreme Court upheld the legality of the revision, but said the exercise does not mean the Election Commission can decide whether a person is an Indian citizen.

Despite this, BJP-ruled states have cited the SIR to deny ration cards to those eliminated from the rolls. In some cases, police have denied permission for their passports to be renewed.

Ten families whose relatives were detained, deported or questioned over their citizenship after being dropped from the revised rolls were interviewed by Reuters. All had Indian identity or family documents, while relatives including parents and siblings remained on the voter lists.

One of them, Sahida Fakir, 38, stepped out of her Mumbai home on July 19 to buy vegetables. More than three months later, she was living in a Bangladeshi village, separated from her husband and two sons.

Fakir said plainclothes officers detained her, seized her phone, which she said contained copies of identity documents, and eventually forced her across the border. Court filings show the officials belonged to the Mumbai police crime branch.

Family records reviewed by Reuters show Fakir’s parents and grandparents were registered voters in Swarupnagar, West Bengal, from India’s first national election in 1952. Their names also appeared on the 2002-03 rolls, a benchmark in the latest revision. Fakir herself has appeared on West Bengal’s electoral rolls since at least 2008.

A petition filed by her family in the Supreme Court in August argued that deletion from the electoral roll could not determine citizenship and that she could not be removed based on an “untested executive assertion.”

In another petition before the Calcutta High Court, utensil hawker Nasiruddin Sheikh and four others said they were detained after their names were removed from the rolls, even though appeals against deletion were pending before special tribunals.

“A policeman told me, ‘Your name is not in the voter list. You are a Bangladeshi,’” Sheikh said.

Call for ‘Country of Particular Concern’

“The Indian government’s expulsion of its own citizens based on their Muslim faith is a shocking escalation of tactics that target religious minorities,” said Gene Mills, a commissioner on the US panel.

Mills urged the State Department to designate India as a “country of particular concern” for its “systematic and egregious” violations of the freedom of religion or belief.

USCIRF is a bipartisan body of the US government that monitors religious freedom around the world and makes policy recommendations, which are not binding. Washington has not acted on its recent recommendations on India. In its 2026 annual report too, the panel had recommended that the State Department designate India as a country of particular concern for engaging in “systematic, ongoing, and egregious religious freedom violations.”

The panel’s statement follows the first remarks by a US lawmaker on the issue. On Wednesday, Indian-origin Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal said she was “deeply concerned” by reports that around 13 crore names had been removed from draft electoral rolls, calling for free and fair elections and backing non-violent protests.

New Delhi Dismisses Criticism

India’s foreign ministry has cast USCIRF as biased. New Delhi has repeatedly dismissed such criticism and called it interference in the country’s internal affairs. The Indian embassy in Washington did not respond to a request for comment.

The Ministry of External Affairs has not yet responded to the commission’s latest allegations. But it has previously said the panel has a “pattern of issuing biased and politically motivated assessments.”

On November 14, the Indian ambassador to the US said the commission should introspect on its “prejudices” and “stop lecturing others,” after the panel shared a profile of jailed activist Sharjeel Imam on social media. The panel had stated a day earlier that Imam is “a Muslim man detained in India for his religious freedom advocacy.” The activist has been in prison for more than six years in the 2020 Delhi riots conspiracy case, registered under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act. The trial is yet to begin.

India’s Election Commission says it was removing duplicate, deceased, shifted and otherwise ineligible voters and that anyone excluded in error can pursue appeals. It has said genuine voters whose names were inadvertently left out can seek inclusion through the claims and objections process and subsequently through Form 6.

The voter-roll revisions sparked protests in recent weeks, with opposition groups and student demonstrators saying the revisions affected those unlikely to vote for the Hindu nationalist BJP. Rights experts condemned India’s crackdown on the protests.

Since October 2, nationwide protests have been held calling for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over concerns about the functioning of the Election Commission and alleged irregularities in how the voter roll is being revised.

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said last month the issue was a “domestic political matter” and Washington would not comment on it.

UN experts and human rights groups say abuse of minorities has risen under Modi.

They point to rising hate speech, a religion-based citizenship law that the UN calls “fundamentally discriminatory,” the demolition of Muslim-owned properties, the removal of Muslim-majority Kashmir’s autonomy and anti-conversion legislation that challenges freedom of belief.

India’s government denies being discriminatory and says its policies, including food subsidy programs and electrification drives, benefit all communities.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Myanmar Guilty of Genocide: The Verdict Is Not the End

The International Court of Justice’s November 2026 judgment marks a...

Urdu-Medium Teachers Oppose Exam for Senior Pay Scale Training in Marathi Only

Teachers’ organisations have written to the state training council,...

Questions Raised as Rajasthan Voter Rolls Show 30 Lakh Variations Across Three Lists

 The November draft electoral roll lists 5.26 crore voters,...

Islam to Replace Christianity as the World’s Largest Religion by 2035

Pew Research Centre projections suggest Muslims will overtake Christians...