Weak Evidence: Allahabad HC Acquits Two Men in Javed Murder Case After 17 Years

Date:

The court sets aside the life sentences awarded to Dilip alias Dalda and Sunil, ruling that the prosecution failed to prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt

PRAYAGRAJ — The Allahabad High Court has acquitted two men convicted in the 2007 murder of Javed in Uttar Pradesh’s Mainpuri district, holding that the prosecution failed to establish their guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

The Division Bench allowed the appeals filed by Dilip alias Dalda and Sunil, setting aside a 2020 trial court judgment that had sentenced both men to life imprisonment.

In its judgment last week, the high court stated that the evidence presented by the prosecution was insufficient to sustain the conviction and that a person cannot be held guilty based on suspicion or weak evidence.

The court observed that the prosecution had failed to prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt, which is the standard required in criminal cases.

During the hearing, the Bench closely examined the testimony of two brothers who had been presented as eyewitnesses.

The court found that they had not actually witnessed the murder.

According to the judgment, the brothers came out of their house only after hearing gunshots. By the time they reached outside, they saw only the alleged assailants riding away on a motorcycle.

The high court noted that the incident had taken place at night and that the suspects were seen only briefly from behind.

In such circumstances, the court held that identifying the accused for the first time during the trial could not be treated as reliable evidence.

The Bench observed that where there was doubt about the identity of the accused, a test identification parade (TIP) should have been conducted during the investigation.

However, the court noted that the police had failed to carry out this important investigative procedure.

The high court also examined the prosecution’s other evidence and found further weaknesses.

It observed that one of the witnesses relied upon by the police to connect the accused with the crime later retracted his earlier statements during the trial, weakening the prosecution’s case.

The Bench further pointed to contradictions in the police investigation regarding the motive behind the murder.

According to the judgment, the investigation initially suggested that the killing was linked to an attempted robbery.

Later, investigators presented a different theory, alleging that the murder had been carried out on contract because of a property dispute.

The court said these conflicting explanations cast serious doubt on the prosecution’s version of events.

It held that no reliable and independent evidence had been produced to establish a direct connection between the accused and the crime.

The court also made critical observations about the quality of the police investigation.

According to the judgment, the available material suggested that the accused may have been implicated in an attempt to show that the case had been solved.

The Bench observed that the prosecution’s case rested largely on assumptions rather than convincing evidence.

It further said the investigation did not produce any independent or trustworthy evidence capable of proving the allegations against the accused.

The court concluded that convictions cannot be sustained where the investigation is weak, the evidence is inconsistent and the prosecution fails to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

In view of these findings, the high court allowed the appeals, overturned the convictions and life sentences imposed by the trial court, and acquitted Dilip alias Dalda and Sunil of the murder charges.

The judgment brings to a close a legal battle that lasted nearly 17 years, highlighting the importance of fair investigation and reliable evidence in criminal trials. The high court emphasised that criminal convictions must be based on credible proof rather than suspicion or inconsistent investigative findings.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

UN Urges Iran, US to Let Fertilisers Through Hormuz Before Millions Sink into Poverty

Before the conflict, a third of the world's fertilisers...

Iran Warns of ‘Immediate and Decisive Response’ to Any New US or Israel Attack

Tehran and Washington envoys spar at the UN, swapping...

Rajasthan Rail Track Blast: Two Hindus Held Over Suspected Links to Pak-Based Handlers

Police claim ISI contract used romance, money to recruit...