Rahul Gandhi’s Israel Line Marks a Break from His Family, Friends, and Party History

Date:

IN one sentence at the University of Chicago, senior Congress leader and the Leader of the Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi did what none of his party leaders in recent memory has done so openly: he made the case for a strong India-Israel relationship — including buying Israeli weapons — as a matter of national interest.

“I support a strong relationship with Israel. We have strategic interests, including buying the best weapons for our armed forces,” Gandhi said during an interaction on Wednesday (November 18), with political scientist Prof Robert Pape on “The Iran War & India’s Role in the World”.

That formulation — strategic ties plus condemnation of Gaza — is the headline break. It puts Gandhi closer to the Narendra Modi government’s balancing act than to his own mother, his sister, and his party’s INDIA bloc allies, who have used far stronger language on Gaza.

Gandhi did not endorse Israel’s war unconditionally. He paired the defence of ties with a double condemnation:

“India’s foreign policy must be guided by what is good for India… But that cannot mean silence on Gaza. I condemn the October 7th attacks and the killing of innocent people. I also condemn what Israel has done in Gaza. One wrong cannot justify another… We are a nation of 1.5 billion people. No country – Israel, USA, Russia or China – should hold us back from playing our rightful role on the global stage. India must stand for what it believes in.”

In the longer exchange, he added: “As far as (our) relationship with Israel goes, there are strategic reasons why we have a relationship with them… We have to buy the best weapons, and they happen to produce very good weapons”.

He also framed the issue as one of sovereignty: India’s relationship with Israel was important, but should not prevent New Delhi from expressing its own position on international developments.

The Congress party itself shared his words from the event, signalling that this was not an off-the-cuff slip but a position the leadership was willing to own publicly.

 

Why It Stings His Allies

The backlash was swift, and it came from inside the INDIA bloc.

On Saturday, former Kerala chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan, whose CPI(M) is a close ally of the Congress at the Centre, said Gandhi’s remarks “expose the Congress party’s glaring hypocrisy on Palestine”.

“His pro-imperialist position undermines the legacy of Nehru, whose foreign policy stood firmly against imperialism and in solidarity with the Palestinian struggle,” Vijayan posted on X.

 

He went further: “At a time when Gaza is witnessing one of the most devastating genocides of our time, with thousands of innocent children among its victims, he openly advocates stronger ties with Israel and arms purchases from a state responsible for their slaughter. His attempt to strike a diplomatic balancing act in the face of this catastrophe is indefensible… There can be no balancing act when humanity is on trial.”

The CPI(ML) Liberation went further still, calling for an end to India’s relationship with Israel altogether. Describing Israel as a “genocidal regime”, its general secretary Dipankar Bhattacharya said there could be no strategic relationship with a State that continued to perpetrate genocide against “children, women and common people despite global condemnation”.

In a fuller statement, the party said: “There can be no independent foreign policy of India which advocates strong strategic ties with Israel,” drawing parallels with Nazi Germany and apartheid South Africa.

Bhattacharya, in a Facebook post sharing a report on Gandhi’s comments, added: “Just as there could be no strategic relationship with Nazi Germany or the apartheid state of South Africa, there can be no normalising, condoning or downplaying of the genocide in Gaza or the cruel colonial occupation of Palestine by Israel.”

He also linked the issue to domestic politics: “India’s existing strategic relationship with Israel, the growing Adani-led corporate trade including arms supply, and sinister use of Israel’s surveillance technology and security model has already done enough damage to India’s international image, foreign policy credibility and, above all, the health of our own internal democracy and governance. We must end it sooner rather than later and must not rationalise it in the name of India’s defence or ‘national security’ needs.”

 

Contrast in the Gandhi Family

The contrast inside the Gandhi family is now impossible to miss.

His sister, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, has been among the most critical voices in the party on Israel. On August 12, 2025, she accused the Israeli government of committing “genocide” and said it is “shameful” that the Indian government is standing “silent” on this. She has also worn Palestine tote bags as a symbol of her support.

His mother, Sonia Gandhi, wrote in an op-ed in The Indian Express in June: “The calculus of national interest demands that we respond to the global public opinion against the Israeli regime’s genocidal actions in Gaza and its brutal displacement and dispossession of lakhs of Palestinian families in the occupied West Bank. The Modi government’s continued silence simply cannot be explained rationally or morally.”

Rahul Gandhi pointedly did not use the word “genocide”. He used “condemn” — for both Hamas and Israel — and paired it with an argument for continued arms purchases.

 

https://youtu.be/kiVjbncsUpI?si=mvt2SZaKLWc-3k4i

 

That difference in vocabulary is now the political story: two Gandhis calling Israel’s actions genocide, one Gandhi calling for strong ties with Israel while condemning what it has done in Gaza.

In response to Priyanka Vadra’s remarks, Israeli Ambassador to India Reuven Azar had said: “What is shameful is your deceit. Israel killed 25,000 Hamas terrorists. The terrible cost in human lives derives from Hamas’s heinous tactics of hiding behind civilians, their shooting of people trying to evacuate or receive assistance and their rocket fire… Israel facilitated 2 million tonnes of food into Gaza while Hamas tries to sequester them, thereby creating hunger. Gaza population has grown 450 per cent in the last 50 years, no genocide there. Don’t buy Hamas numbers.”

Congress defends, BJP attacks — but on a different front

Inside the Congress, leaders moved to defend Gandhi. Congress leaders Supriya Shrinate and Shama Mohamed backed him, citing India’s strategic and defence interests in maintaining ties with Israel. Shama Mohamed stressed that he had condemned Israel’s actions in Gaza while emphasising that India’s foreign policy must serve its own interests.

The BJP, meanwhile, attacked Gandhi not primarily over Israel but over his broader foreign-policy remarks in Chicago — where he said India had become a “side player” in global affairs as Pakistan played a role in negotiating peace between the US and Iran.

BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari called Gandhi a “Pak fan boy” for raising questions over the government’s foreign policy abroad, while national spokesperson C R Kesavan accused him of attempting to tarnish India’s international reputation.

The irony was not lost on critics: on Israel, Gandhi sounded closer to the Modi government than to his own allies; on India’s global standing, he sounded like the government’s sharpest critic — and was attacked for it.

A break — but not without precedent

Gandhi’s remarks seem to be a moderation, not an invention.

Congress history on Palestine is long and deeply Nehruvian. Jawaharlal Nehru in 1938 declared: “Palestine is essentially an Arab country and must remain so, and the Arabs must not be crushed and suppressed in their own homelands”. After independence, India opposed the 1947 UN partition plan for Palestine, voted against the creation of Israel at the UN, and became the first non-Arab country to recognise Palestine as an independent state.

Yet even Nehru quietly sought Israeli weapons at the height of the 1962 China-India war, according to Israeli archives. And it was a Congress government that normalised full diplomatic relations with Israel in 1992, with an eye on diversifying weapons procurement.

Today, India is the largest buyer of Israeli arms, accounting for nearly 37 per cent of Israel’s total arms exports.

What changed after October 7, 2023, was the party’s public language. The Congress initially refrained from naming Hamas and using the word “terror” to describe the attacks. Party leader Shashi Tharoor questioned this at a meeting of the Congress Working Committee on October 9, 2023, seeking a resolution condemning the attacks, naming the outfit and using the word terror.

While the CWC ignored the suggestion, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge soon afterwards condemned “the brutal attacks by Hamas on the people of Israel”, adding that “the indiscriminate actions by Israel’s military forces in civilian areas, that include a siege of the Gaza Strip and bombings in it” were also “unacceptable”.

Later, the Congress joined Left parties in slamming the Modi government after India abstained from voting at the UN General Assembly on a resolution drafted by Arab states calling for an immediate truce between Israel and Hamas and demanding aid access to Gaza.

Gandhi’s Chicago formulation returns to that Kharge-era balance — condemn both sides, keep ties — but goes one step further by explicitly justifying arms purchases as a strategic necessity.

That is why the Left reaction has been so sharp. For Vijayan and Bhattacharya, the issue is not tone but trade: buying weapons, they argue, is not neutrality, it is complicity.

Critics outside the bloc have made the same point more bluntly, saying “neutrality in the face of genocide is complicity” and arguing that when nations are severing ties with Israel, calling for strong ties normalises its actions in Gaza.

 

—————

 

Syed Athar Hasnain Rizvi is a senior journalist. He was associated with the National Herald in New Delhi and the Saudi Gazette in Jeddah. He can be contacted at: [email protected]

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Rahul Gandhi’s Israel Line Marks a Break from His Family, Friends, and Party History

IN one sentence at the University of Chicago, senior...

Rajasthan’s Five Historic Mosques, Dargahs Reflect Its Architectural, Spiritual Heritage

From Ajmer Sharif to Galakot and Narhar, these religious...

House Church Attacked in West Bengal, Christians Allege Police Inaction, Threats

Pastor and worshippers, including women and children, were allegedly...

Dainik Jagran Enters Kolkata Six Months After BJP Assumes Power in West Bengal

The Hindi newspaper has opened an office in Kasba...