Home EDITOR'S PICK Press Club of India Condemns FIR Against Maktoob Media, Seeks Prompt Withdrawal

Press Club of India Condemns FIR Against Maktoob Media, Seeks Prompt Withdrawal

0
Press Club of India Condemns FIR Against Maktoob Media, Seeks Prompt Withdrawal

The journalists’ body says Maktoob merely reported allegations by TMC MP Mahua Moitra; questions police action


NEW DELHI —
The Press Club of India (PCI) has strongly condemned the First Information Report (FIR) registered by the West Bengal Police against online news portal Maktoob Media over its reporting on allegations made by Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra. The journalists’ body has called for the case to be withdrawn immediately, describing the police action as an attack on press freedom.

The FIR relates to reports and social media posts by Maktoob Media about Moitra’s allegations that senior Muslim IAS and IPS officers were excluded from official meetings during Union Home Minister Amit Shah’s visits to West Bengal. The TMC leader publicly raised the allegations, and several media organisations subsequently reported them.

In a statement issued on Saturday, the Press Club of India said the allegations had been made publicly by Moitra and had received widespread media coverage. The organisation noted that no official denial of the allegations had been issued, yet police had proceeded with filing an FIR against Maktoob Media.

The PCI also expressed concern that Maktoob Media was not informed directly by the police about the case. According to the statement, the organisation learned about the FIR only after receiving a communication from social media platform X. The Press Club further noted that police had sought details relating to the creation and login history of Maktoob’s X account as well as Android device information linked to the account.

Although the FIR reportedly lists the accused as an “unknown person”, the Press Club said it specifically referred to Maktoob Media’s social media posts.

The journalists’ body also pointed out that the National Commission for Minorities had already taken cognisance of Moitra’s complaint and sought a report from the West Bengal government regarding the allegations.

“It is the job of journalists to report serious allegations of this nature,” the Press Club said in its statement. It described the police action against Maktoob Media as unjustified and called the FIR “an attack on press freedom and part of the pattern to attempt to stop any independent journalism in the country.”

The Press Club urged the West Bengal Police to withdraw the FIR immediately and ensure that journalists are able to carry out their professional duties without fear or pressure. The statement was signed by PCI President Sangeeta Barooah Pisharoty and Secretary General Afzal Imam.

The FIR against Maktoob Media was registered at the Bidhannagar Cyber Crime Police Station on 19 September following a complaint over the outlet’s reporting and social media posts concerning Moitra’s allegations. According to reports, the case invokes several provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita relating to alleged promotion of enmity, public mischief and defamation. These allegations remain untested in court.

Moitra had alleged that senior Muslim officers were excluded from official meetings and protocol duties during Amit Shah’s visits to West Bengal.