Lessons from The Hague: What Rohingya Genocide Ruling Means for India

Date:

The World Court has found Myanmar guilty of genocide. Its judgment is also a map of how a state slides from prejudice to atrocity, and we as a nation would be wise to read it closely

Syed Akmal Razvi | Clarion India

ON 19 November 2026, the International Court of Justice did something it had never done in its 80-year history: it found a State responsible for committing genocide. By nine votes to six, the court held in The Gambia v. Myanmar that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State during the military’s 2017 “clearance operations”. The ICJ accepted that at least 10,000 Rohingya were killed. More than 700,000 people, over 85 per cent of the Rohingya who remained in northern Rakhine, fled to Bangladesh.

Myanmar has been ordered to prosecute those responsible, enact a genocide law, allow refugees to return safely, restore their property and pay compensation, reporting back to the court within two years. Those are the headlines. The more important story, lies in the 191 pages of reasoning: in how the court explained what came before the killing.

Genocide Does Not Begin with Killing

The court treated Myanmar’s conduct as the context from which genocidal intent could be inferred: discriminatory laws, hate speech, earlier military operations, and forced displacement. Individually, said the court, none proved intent. Together, they formed the framework within which the killings acquired their meaning.

The first strand was paperwork. Myanmar’s 1982 Citizenship Law did not expressly exclude the Rohingya. The exclusion came through implementation: the State left them off its official list of 135 “national races”, and “onerous and discriminatory” verification procedures denied citizenship even to Rohingya who could document their entitlement. Identity cards declared holders to be non-citizens and required them to call themselves “Bengali”. Access to travel, jobs and higher education depended on those cards. The result, by the government’s own advisory commission’s count, was about one million stateless people.

The second strand was the politics of population. A regional order in force from 2005 to 2018 required Muslims in Maungdaw to seek permission to marry and to limit their children. Officials described these measures, in writing, as “Processes for Controlling Bengali Population”. The court noted that Myanmar imposed no similar restrictions on other groups or regions, even where birth rates were higher. Birth registration of Rohingya children stopped altogether; by 2013 some 60,000 children were unregistered.

The court’s conclusion is the sentence every  administrator should remember: these systems were “discriminatory both by design and in their implementation, rendering the Rohingya marginalised and particularly vulnerable”.

Words From the Top

The third strand was speech, and here the judgment is most instructive. The court defined hate speech simply: pejorative language that is derogatory towards a group or dehumanises it. It then traced how such speech moved from the margins to the centre of the State.

After communal violence in 2012, monks’ sermons and the media increasingly portrayed the Rohingya as deceitful, dangerous foreigners. Then the State itself took up the theme. While the 2017 operations were under way, the army chief, Senior General Min Aung Hlaing, called the “Bengali problem” an “unfinished job”, warned that the Bengali population had “exploded”, and declared that a “race cannot be swallowed by the ground but only by another race”. His words echoed a 2012 army training lecture titled “Fear of Extinction of Race”.

Alongside, the military ran a coordinated network of Facebook pages, including the army chief’s own page with 1.4 million followers. Investigators found 10,485 pieces of anti-Rohingya hate content on 36 of those pages in just six months of 2017. The posts called Rohingya “animals”, warned of their “rampant breeding”, and told Buddhists to “sharpen even the knives at home”. One post the court quoted urged Myanmar to copy India’s alleged “shoot-to-kill policy” against “Bengalis” at the border. A single official post the day before the operations drew more than 200 comments calling for Rohingya to be killed or expelled.

There is a nuance here that matters. By 14 votes to one, the court held that this speech did not amount to “direct and public incitement” to genocide. Incitement requires a direct call to destroy a group, and the evidence fell short of that. But the court still treated hate speech as a building block of genocidal intent, especially because it came from “a high-ranking government official” and was “organised by governmental authorities”. It found that the speech portrayed the Rohingya “both as subhuman and as a violent threat, thus contributing to a climate conducive to targeting a group for destruction”.

The lesson is uncomfortable but clear. Rhetoric that stays just short of an explicit call to violence is no legal safe harbour. When those in power speak this way, the words become evidence, against them and against the State.

Let us be precise, because precision is the point. India is not Myanmar. It is a constitutional democracy with a Supreme Court that has repeatedly stepped in, a free if embattled press, competitive elections, federalism and a vigorous civil society. Nobody seriously claims that what happened in Rakhine is happening in India. But the court’s judgment is not only about the final catastrophe; it is about the road to it. And several of the warning signs it identified have recognisable echoes here.

Citizenship through paperwork. Assam’s National Register of Citizens, published in 2019, left out 19.06 lakh people. Seven years on, many are struggling with appeals before Foreigners Tribunals, leaving them, as “neither citizens nor foreigners”. Myanmar’s lesson is that exclusion rarely arrives by an explicit law. It arrives through procedures that the vulnerable cannot satisfy.

The language of the outsider. Myanmar officially recast the Rohingya as “Bengali” illegal immigrants. In India, the vocabulary of the “infiltrator” has entered mainstream political speech. The India Hate Lab, a Washington-based research group, documented 1,318 in-person hate speech events in 2025, 13 per cent more than in 2024 and almost double the 2023 count; 98 per cent targeted Muslims. The authorities dispute its methodology, and its findings should be read with that in mind. But the trend it records, including recurring claims that minorities are a demographic threat, mirrors precisely the “fear of extinction” narrative the court found so dangerous in Myanmar.

Collective punishment. In Rakhine, Rohingya villages were burned and bulldozed. The authorities in India started demolishing homes of people accused of crimes, popularly called “bulldozer justice”, spread across several states until the Supreme Court, in November 2024, declared such demolitions unconstitutional and made officials personally liable for violations.

Institutions under strain. In 2022 and 2023, the Supreme Court ordered police in every state to register hate speech cases on their own, without waiting for a complaint. In April 2026, however, it closed the long-pending batch of hate speech petitions, holding that existing laws were adequate and that there was no “legislative vacuum”. Enforcement now rests with the police and the High Courts. Karnataka passed a dedicated hate speech law in December 2025, but the Governor has reserved it for the President’s consideration, and critics have argued that its definitions are too vague.

A missing law. India ratified the Genocide Convention in 1959, yet it has never enacted a domestic law defining and punishing genocide. Neither the Indian Penal Code nor its successor, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, contains such an offence. The ICJ held, by 14 votes to one, that Myanmar breached the convention precisely by failing to enact such legislation.

Why it is a Matter of National Interest

Some will say that raising these concerns harms India’s image. The opposite is true. What harms the national interest is letting such patterns harden.

Consider what Myanmar has lost. Its army, which led the 2017 operations, overthrew the constitutional order in 2021 and the country has since descended into a potential bankrupt state. It now stands formally adjudged a genocidal State, under a binding obligation to pay reparations and to report to the world court, and its leaders face the prospect of criminal accountability for decades. No amount of nationalist rhetoric has spared it that.

Our aspirations as a county run in the opposite direction: a permanent seat on the Security Council, a leading voice for the Global South, a destination for global capital and talent. Each depends on India being seen as a country that protects its minorities under the rule of law. Every hate-filled rally clip that circulates abroad is evidence that India’s rivals will gladly use. And a nation of 1.4 billion cannot grow while a large share of its citizens is made to feel like suspects.

There is also a hard security logic. Communities pushed to the margins become fertile ground for radicalisation, and a climate of hatred makes every terror attack or border flare-up a trigger for internal violence. The India Hate Lab’s own data show hate events spiking in the fortnight after the Pahalgam attack in 2025. Social cohesion is not a soft value; it is a strategic asset. 

What We as a Nation Should Do Now

The ICJ’s remedies for Myanmar double as a checklist for prevention. We can adopt them by choice, long before anyone could seek to impose them.

1. Enact a genocide and atrocity-crimes law: Sixty-seven years after ratifying the Genocide Convention, India should finally give effect to Article V, defining genocide, incitement and crimes against humanity in domestic law.

2. Hold the powerful to the highest standard of speech: The court gave special weight to words spoken by senior officials. Political parties should adopt and enforce codes of conduct, and the Election Commission should act firmly and even-handedly against communal campaigning.

3. Enforce existing law without fear or favour: The Supreme Court has held that the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita already covers hate speech, including promoting enmity between groups. The test of good faith is equal enforcement, whatever the religion or party of the speaker.

4. Make citizenship processes humane and fair: Nobody who has lived in India for generations should be rendered stateless by a documentation test they cannot pass. The Assam NRC appeals must be brought to a just conclusion, with legal aid for those excluded.

5. Hold platforms to account: Myanmar’s genocide was amplified on Facebook. Social media companies operating in India must detect and remove coordinated hate campaigns, in every Indian language, before they go viral.

6. Build early warning into our institutions: The National Human Rights Commission and the National Commission for Minorities should monitor hate speech and discriminatory policies systematically and report to Parliament every year.

The judgment of 19 November is, above all, a record of missed chances. Myanmar had decades in which to stop: when it wrote the citizenship rules, when it restricted marriages, when its generals began speaking of “unfinished jobs”. At each stage the harm looked bureaucratic, rhetorical, deniable.

Our founders wrote a Constitution that promises equality before the law and fraternity among all its people precisely so that our great country would never walk that road. Honouring that promise is not a concession to any community. It is the surest defence of the nation itself.

___________________

Syed Akmal Razvi is a lawyer practising in the Karnataka High Court. The views expressed here are the author’s own, and Clarion India does not necessarily subscribe to them. He can be contacted at [email protected]

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

Mosque, Shahi Maqbara and Over a Dozen Shrines Razed in Ujjain Ahead of Simhastha 2028

The demolition has drawn strong objections from the Waqf...

Christian Families Allege Attacks, Forced Conversion Attempts in West Bengal

Two separate incidents in Purba and Paschim Medinipur have...

Does ICJ’s ‘Genocidal Intent’ Ruling on Myanmar Pave the Path For a Similar Finding Against Israel?

The judgment broadens what counts as destroying a ‘substantial...