Global Media Group Sees Witch-hunt Against Zubair and Naqvi


Noting that the two scribes have been targeted on account of their religious identity, the Committee to Protect Journalists asked police to drop investigations into their social media posts.

Team Clarion

NEW DELHI — The Committee to Protect Journalists has asked the police to drop investigations into social media posts criticising right-wing Hindu politics and activists of journalists, Saba Naqvi and Mohammed Zubair.

Noting that the two scribes have been targeted on account of their religious identity, the global media rights group urged the government to allow them to work freely.

On June 3, the police in the Sitapur district of Uttar Pradesh initiated an investigation into Zubair, co-founder of the fact-checking website Alt News after he tweeted that three rightwing Hindu activists were “Hate Mongers”, according to news reports.

On June 8, the police in New Delhi opened an investigation into Naqvi, a freelance journalist, after she shared a satirical meme on her Twitter account about a recent claim that a revered symbol connected to the Hindu deity Shiva had been found in a mosque in the northern Varanasi city, according to various news reports.

The meme was shared by several Twitter users, including a member of parliament, and republished by the financial newspaper Economic Times. However, only Naqvi, who is a Muslim and known for her criticism of the rightwing Hindu politics, was named in the investigation.

This is the second social media-connected investigation into Naqvi, and the fifth into Zubair, according to those reports.

Both the journalists use social media as part of their job, according to CPJ’s review of their social media accounts. “Indian police need to stop targeting journalists who are critical of sectarian politics,” said Steven Butler, CPJ’s Asia program coordinator, in Washington, D.C.
“Selective investigations into Mohammed Zubair and Saba Naqvi strongly suggest that they are being unacceptably targeted because of their Muslim religious identity and work as journalists,” Butler said.

Police are investigating Zubair under Section 295(a) of the penal code for “deliberate and malicious acts” intended to create religious outrage and Section 67 of the Information Technology Act for “publishing or transmitting obscene material,” according to those reports. He faces three years imprisonment under Section 295(a) and an additional three years and a fine of Rs 5,00,000 (US$6,400) under Section 67.

According to the reports, Bhagwan Sharan, who identified himself as the district head of Hindu rightwing group Rashtriya Hindu Sher Sena, filed the complaint against Zubair. On June 13, the Allahabad High Court declined Zubair’s plea to end the investigation, according to the independent news website Zubair did not respond to CPJ’s text message asking for comment.

The police are investigating Naqvi for violations of the penal code under Section 153 for “promoting enmity” between groups, Section 295, and Section 505 for inducing others to commit offenses against the state or “public tranquility,” according to those sources. She faces six months imprisonment under Section 153, two years imprisonment under Section 295, and five years imprisonment under Section 505, according to the law. Each section also carries an unstated fine, the CPJ statement said.

The complaint against Naqvi was filed by the Intelligence Fusion and Strategic Operation unit of the Special Cell of Delhi Police for “inciting various groups and creating situations that are detrimental to the maintenance of public tranquility in the country,” according to the independent outlet India Today.

“I was shocked,” Naqvi told CPJ by text message. “[This investigation has] implications for free speech in India, suggesting that there can be cherry-picking to target certain journalists.”

Suman Nalwa, New Delhi’s police spokesperson, and Uttar Pradesh police did not immediately respond to CPJ’s text message and email requesting comment, the statement concludes.

Saba Naqvi and Mohammed Zubair.
Clarion India - News, Views and Insights about Indian Muslims, Dalits, Minorities, Women and Other Marginalised and Dispossessed Communities.

Share post:


More like this

Opposition Silence on Lynchings, Attacks on Muslims Questioned

In continuing assaults on the Muslim community, four men...

68 Indians Among 922 Haj Pilgrims Die Due to Heatstroke in Makkah

The highest number of casualties came from Egypt, at...

It is Said PM Stopped Ukraine-Russia War But He is Unable to Stop Exam Paper Leaks: Rahul Gandhi

Nothing should be done in arbitrary manner, rules that...

PM Conducts Grand Tamasha of Pareeksha Pe Charcha, Can’t Conduct Exams Without Leaks, Frauds: Congress

The Opposition party also asked the 'non-biological PM' if...