Calcutta High Court Orders Restoration of Ration Benefits Despite Deletion in SIR

Date:

KOLKATA — Ration benefits cannot be discontinued merely because a person’s name has been deleted from the electoral roll during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise, the Calcutta High Court has ruled. The court directed the immediate restoration of supplies suspended on this ground and asked the West Bengal government to clarify its stand at the next hearing.

The order was passed on July 30 by Justice Hiranmay Bhattacharyya while hearing a writ petition challenging the suspension of ration benefits after deletion from the voter list.

During the hearing, the court observed that removal from the electoral roll does not automatically make a person ineligible for benefits under the Public Distribution System (PDS). Justice Bhattacharyya noted that there is no direct legal nexus between a citizen’s right to receive subsidised food under the food security framework and inclusion in the electoral roll, and that the issue requires wider consideration.

According to the petitioner, her name was deleted from the electoral roll during the SIR process. She alleged that the local ration dealer then informed her and others that their ration benefits would be stopped.

Contending that the decision violated her legal right to food security, the petitioner approached the high court seeking restoration of supplies.

The court directed that ration benefits be restored immediately where they were discontinued solely because a person’s name had been removed from the voter list. It also directed the state government to place its position on record at the next hearing.

The petition, filed by Umme Salma, challenged a June 4 order issued by the Special Secretary, Food & Supplies Department. The department had decided to undertake “verification and deletion of those PDS beneficiaries who have been found ineligible” following the completion of the SIR and publication of final electoral rolls. Categories under scrutiny included persons marked as Absentee, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD) electors, those whose applications were rejected during SIR, and those deleted during the exercise.

 

The Legal Distinction

The Supreme Court has clarified that the SIR is meant solely for election-related purposes and cannot be treated as a basis for determining citizenship or depriving people of other civil benefits. It has also observed that exclusion from electoral rolls under SIR neither establishes loss of citizenship nor determines economic vulnerability, which are unrelated to food security eligibility.

 

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

UN Urges Iran, US to Let Fertilisers Through Hormuz Before Millions Sink into Poverty

Before the conflict, a third of the world's fertilisers...

Iran Warns of ‘Immediate and Decisive Response’ to Any New US or Israel Attack

Tehran and Washington envoys spar at the UN, swapping...

Rajasthan Rail Track Blast: Two Hindus Held Over Suspected Links to Pak-Based Handlers

Police claim ISI contract used romance, money to recruit...