Keshav Prasad Maurya’s call for Mathura after Ayodhya has renewed debate, the RSS position on temple disputes and questions surrounding the party’s record in Uttar Pradesh
MATHURA — The Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) preparations for the 2027 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections have brought the Mathura temple dispute back into political debate after Deputy Chief Minister Keshav Prasad Maurya declared, “Ayodhya is ours, now it is Mathura’s turn,” and challenged Samajwadi Party (SP) president Akhilesh Yadav to undertake kar seva in Mathura.
The statement followed a two-day BJP planning meeting in Mathura. The meeting was attended by Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, both deputy chief ministers, state BJP president Pankaj Chaudhary, national general secretary (organisation) BL Santhosh and national president Nitin Naveen.
The developments have prompted questions from political commentators and critics about whether the BJP is preparing to revive temple-related disputes as an election issue. An editorial published by IndiaSpeak Daily has questioned the party’s approach, comparing its latest statements on Mathura with its previous positions, its record in Ayodhya and its policies concerning minorities in Uttar Pradesh.
RSS Position on Temple Disputes
One of the questions raised in the editorial concerns the apparent difference between the BJP’s current political messaging and earlier statements by Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) chief Mohan Bhagwat.
In June 2022, while addressing an RSS programme in Nagpur during the Gyanvapi mosque dispute, Bhagwat questioned the practice of looking for Shivlings in every mosque.
“Why look for a Shivling in every mosque?” he asked.
He also said that the RSS had become involved in the Ram Janmabhoomi movement because of the historical circumstances at the time, but would not launch fresh movements over Kashi and Mathura. He suggested that such disputes should be resolved through mutual agreement or the courts.
The IndiaSpeak Daily editorial questions why the BJP is now bringing Mathura to the forefront of its political campaign when the RSS chief had previously indicated that the organisation would not initiate similar movements.
It asks whether the renewed emphasis on Mathura represents a change in ideological priorities or an electoral strategy ahead of the 2027 polls, especially in the context of the Samajwadi Party’s PDA (Pichhda, Dalit, Alpsankhyak) political formula.
Questions Over Ayodhya Land Deals
The editorial also raises questions about the BJP’s record in Ayodhya, particularly concerning land transactions, temple construction and the handling of donations.
A report by Nai Dunia on the BJP’s Mathura meeting said the party was preparing to respond to opposition criticism over issues including the University Grants Commission (UGC), reservation, Gen-Z and allegations of irregularities in Ram temple donations.
Journalist Ajeet Bharti also criticised the renewed emphasis on Mathura in a social media post, writing: “You began with the alleged theft of Ram temple donations; now you have abandoned Ram and taken hold of Kanha. Have you no shame left?”
The controversy over land transactions in Ayodhya dates back to June 2021, when the purchase of 1.208 hectares of land in Bagh Bijaisi village for Rs 18.5 crore attracted political criticism. Reports at the time said the same land had been registered for Rs 2 crore just minutes before the subsequent transaction.
Media reports in December 2021 also raised questions about land purchases around Ayodhya, particularly in the Barhata Manjha area, following the Supreme Court’s 2019 verdict in the Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid dispute. The reports referred to land purchases by relatives of senior administrative officials and elected representatives.
The editorial further recalls concerns about the quality of temple construction. In June 2024, Acharya Satyendra Das, the chief priest of the Ram temple at the time, publicly said that water had leaked through the roof of the sanctum during the first heavy rainfall.
Questions were also raised during the January 2024 consecration ceremony. Shankaracharyas associated with the four principal Hindu religious seats expressed objections to holding the ceremony while the temple was incomplete. Among those who voiced their opposition were Swami Avimukteshwaranand Saraswati of Jyotirmath and Swami Nishchalanand Saraswati of Puri.
They referred to religious texts, including traditions concerning Vastu Shastra and Agama, in questioning the timing of the consecration ceremony. They did not participate in the event.
Allegations Over Donations and Construction Expenditure
The handling of donations collected in the name of the Ram temple is another issue raised in the editorial.
It alleges that funds contributed by devotees in India and abroad were subject to financial irregularities and questions why a transparent public audit report covering the donations has not been made available.
The editorial also refers to alleged irregularities in temple construction expenditure and land acquisition, citing the role of a revenue official identified as Lekhpal Mahipal.
According to the editorial, Mahipal exposed alleged financial irregularities involving construction work, land compensation and government expenditure on the basis of official records. It alleges that the arrangements resulted in losses worth crores of rupees to the public exchequer and temple funds.
Muslim Representation in the OBC List
The editorial also draws attention to the representation of Muslim communities in Uttar Pradesh’s Other Backward Classes (OBC) list.
Citing a Hindustan Times report published in May 2024, it says that 38 of the 79 communities listed as OBCs in the state are Muslim sub-castes.
The report also stated that the list had last been revised in 2002 and that no communities had been added or removed since then.
The editorial questions why the state government, despite having been in power with a full majority for much of the past decade, has not undertaken a comprehensive review through the State Backward Classes Commission to address possible inequalities in the classification.
It also points to earlier administrative discussions about revising the list, arguing that these have not resulted in a fresh revision.
Madrasa Funding and Minority Welfare Schemes
The editorial raises questions about what it describes as a contradiction in the BJP government’s approach towards Muslims.
It criticises the political use of Hindu-Muslim issues while pointing to government allocations for madrasa education and minority welfare under the Yogi Adityanath administration.
According to the editorial, Uttar Pradesh’s budgets for 2023-24 and 2024-25 together provided more than Rs 1,000 crore under the Minority Welfare Department for madrasa modernisation, teachers’ honorariums and scholarships for minority students.
The government’s stated justification for madrasa modernisation funding is that it supports the teaching of subjects such as science, mathematics and computer studies alongside religious education.
Critics cited in the editorial question the use of public money for religious education and describe the allocations as an extension of what they regard as minority appeasement.
The editorial also refers to figures circulated through BJP minority wing platforms and government-related presentations concerning Muslim beneficiaries of central welfare schemes.
It says Muslims, who account for approximately 14-15 per cent of India’s population, have been reported to constitute around 31 per cent of beneficiaries under the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana, 37 per cent under the Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana and between 33 and 36 per cent under the PM-Kisan Samman Nidhi and Mudra schemes.
The BJP has presented the participation of Muslims in welfare programmes as evidence of its Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikaspolicy. Critics of the party’s Hindutva politics, meanwhile, have questioned how these figures fit into the party’s political messaging on minority communities.
The editorial does not provide the underlying beneficiary datasets or the methodology used to calculate these percentages.
UP’s Share in Meat Exports
Another issue raised in the editorial concerns the meat-processing and export industry in Uttar Pradesh.
Citing annual reports of the Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (APEDA), which functions under the Union Ministry of Commerce, it says Uttar Pradesh accounts for the largest share of India’s meat exports.
For 2023-24, the editorial puts India’s total meat exports at more than Rs 31,000 crore and estimates that processing units in Uttar Pradesh accounted for between 55 and 60 per cent of the total, worth more than Rs 17,000 crore.
The figures have been cited to question the contrast between the state government’s public position on cow protection and its handling of the meat-processing industry.
The Yogi Adityanath government has highlighted action against illegal slaughterhouses and enforcement of laws intended to protect cattle. Critics, however, point to the expansion of licensed slaughterhouses and meat-processing facilities in the state.
The editorial also raises allegations that beef exports are taking place under the category of bovine meat, which includes buffalo meat. It suggests that this classification is being used to conceal the export of cow meat.
It also refers to a statement attributed to BJP MLA Nand Kishor Gurjar, who reportedly claimed that 50,000 cows were being slaughtered every day in Uttar Pradesh.
The editorial further alleges that around 70 lakh cattle have gone missing in the state. It cites this figure in support of its criticism of the government’s cattle protection record, but does not provide the underlying official data or explain how the figure was calculated.
Mathura Returns to the Centre of Vote Politics
The editorial argues that the BJP’s renewed focus on Mathura should be viewed in the context of its preparations for the 2027 Assembly elections.
It also refers to a proposed programme on 28 November involving five chief ministers, which it sees as part of the party’s efforts to bring the Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi issue into the political spotlight.
Questioning the BJP’s intentions, the editorial argues that the party has had full-majority governments at the Centre and in Uttar Pradesh for much of the past decade and could have pursued a legislative route if it had wanted to resolve the Krishna Janmabhoomi dispute.
It asks why the government has not introduced legislation or an ordinance on the issue and accuses the BJP of using religious sentiment to strengthen its electoral position.
The editorial further criticises the party’s approach to the legacy of the Ayodhya movement. It refers to the Padma Vibhushan awarded to former Uttar Pradesh chief minister Mulayam Singh Yadav, whose government had ordered police firing on kar sevaks during the Ayodhya movement.
It also points to the appointment of Nripendra Misra, who had served as principal secretary to the Prime Minister, as chairman of the construction committee of the Shri Ram Janmabhoomi temple.
The editorial interprets these decisions as evidence of what it describes as the BJP’s inconsistent political position on the Ayodhya movement. It argues that the party’s renewed call for kar seva in Mathura sits uneasily with its record on the earlier movement.
It concludes that the BJP is seeking to revive temple-related mobilisation ahead of the 2027 elections and alleges that communal polarisation has repeatedly helped the party electorally in Uttar Pradesh.

