Bharuch’s Jama Masjid and Jain Shrine Claim: Gujarat HC Directs ASI Probe

Date:

A petition by five applicants claims the 14th-century mosque was built on a Jain pilgrimage site, while the Mahanubhav sect separately asserts it was the birthplace of its founder

BHARUCH — A dispute over the history of Bharuch’s centuries-old Jama Masjid has entered a new phase after five petitioners approached the Gujarat High Court, claiming the protected monument was once a Jain religious site. The court has asked the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to examine the matter and has sought a response from the Union government.

The petitioners want the building declared a Jain temple and seek protection for an image they identify as that of Mallinath, the 19th Jain Tirthankara. They also seek permission to worship at the site, arguing that the structure was formerly known as Ashwabhod Tirth and Shakunika Vihar.

The claims have not been established by a judicial finding. The mosque is under ASI control and is used for Muslim prayers, while a separate claim over its origins has been advanced by the Maharashtra-based Mahanubhav sect, which says the site was the birthplace of its founder, Chakradhar Swami.

 

Petition Cites Carvings and ‘ídols’

The five petitioners include Delhi residents Harishankar Jain and Rahul Diwan, along with three others. Their plea reportedly refers to carved features and figures on the building, including depictions of elephants, horses and dancing women, which they argue are consistent with an earlier Jain religious structure.

The petition also states that the ASI declared the Jama Masjid a protected monument in 1909 and that it is listed among buildings of national importance. The petitioners argue that its status under the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958, means its existing character cannot lawfully be altered.

Harishankar Jain told Media Gujarati that he was pursuing legal cases seeking the restoration of temples at several sites across India. He alleged that temples had been demolished in the past and mosques constructed in their place, and asserted that Bharuch’s building was originally a Jain temple.

Jain also claimed that photographs attached to the petition showed religious figures and that numerous idols remained in a basement beneath the mosque.

The controversy intensified after videos circulated on social media in March, reportedly showing people entering the mosque and women attempting to perform worship after placing coconuts and other items there. In June, another video allegedly recorded inside the basement circulated with claims that idols had been found there.

Mosque Trustees Dispute Temple Claim

Imran Patel, a trustee of the Jama Masjid, gave a different account of the building’s history. He said the mosque had long been known as the Jamia Masjid and was built after local rulers provided land to Muslim traders who had arrived when Bharuch was an important port.

Patel acknowledged that material from a Jain temple may have been used during construction, but denied that a temple had been demolished at the site to make way for the mosque. He said the construction proceeded slowly because local craftsmen were unfamiliar with mosque architecture and that reused temple material was available in the market.

Responding to claims about idols in the basement, Patel said the building was under ASI control and that objects could not simply be removed from it. He suggested that a carved stone fragment might have been reused in a pillar at some point, but argued that this would not prove that the mosque had been built after demolishing a temple.

Patel also alleged that people from outside Bharuch were driving the dispute and attempting to disturb local peace. He said the mosque’s trustees had not yet been made parties to the legal proceedings.

Following the recent controversy, the report said, visitors’ names and telephone numbers are being recorded before they enter the premises.

The mosque continues to host the five daily Muslim prayers.

Mahanubhav Sect Advances Separate Claim

The dispute is not confined to the Jain petitioners and the mosque’s Muslim trustees. The Maharashtra-based Mahanubhav sect, founded by Chakradhar Swami, has also claimed the site as the founder’s birthplace.

Sudarshan Nagraj Kapate, secretary of the Mahanubhav Devasthan Trust in Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar, previously said Chakradhar Swami was born at the location and that it had been a place of worship dating to the 12th century. He claimed a religious structure had been demolished there to build the mosque.

Kapate has also linked the site to a Jain family tradition, saying Chakradhar Swami was born Haripaldev, the son of Bharuch’s royal family, and that the location was associated with the name Samli Vihar Jain Temple. No archaeological evidence has been presented to substantiate the Mahanubhav sect’s claims about the site.

When approached again for comment, Kapate reportedly said he worked under the guidance of Muktanand Swami, associated with a monastery in Bharuch, and would agree with his position.

Muktanand Swami, formerly known as Bhavesh Patel, also asserted that the mosque was the birthplace of Chakradhar Swami. He argued that its carvings and figures were inconsistent with a mosque and accused authorities of failing to enforce archaeological rules at the site.

He further alleged that ablution facilities had been built, water taps installed and burials carried out in the cemetery despite restrictions.

Muktanand Swami was convicted in the 2007 Ajmer Dargah bombing case by a trial court in 2017 and sentenced to life imprisonment. The Rajasthan High Court granted him bail in 2018.

What the Historical Record Says

The Gujarat government’s Bharuch district website describes the Jama Masjid as a 14th-century structure built using remains and material from an older Jain temple. It places the building near the foot of Bharuch Fort and dates its structure to around the beginning of the 14th century, approximately 1300.

The government account describes three large domes and 48 pillars arranged with bracketed supports. It says material associated with a temple was reused in the construction, while the building itself was designed according to mosque principles. Local workers carried out the construction with guidance from Muslim supervisors, according to the account.

This historical description supports the view that material from an earlier religious structure was incorporated into the mosque. It does not, by itself, establish the petitioners’ claim that the present building should legally be declared a Jain temple, nor does it resolve the separate Mahanubhav claim that the location was Chakradhar Swami’s birthplace.

The distinction is important: the reuse of architectural material from an earlier structure is not necessarily proof that the entire building was originally a temple or that a particular religious community has an established right to worship there.

An ASI official, Rijju Ghosh, previously told Media Gujarati that the monument had been functioning as a mosque since it came under the 1958 monuments law, and that he could not comment on what the site had been before that. ASI Vadodara Circle superintendent Dr Shubh Majumdar had earlier said the building was open to visitors and that people were not being prevented from entering it.

The central questions now before the court concern the evidence supporting the competing historical claims, the status of the protected monument and what, if any, legal relief can be granted without violating protections governing the site.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

History Conference in Bhopal Emphasises on Authentic Sources and Unbiased Accounts

BHOPAL — At the two-day History Conference that began...

US Religious Freedom Body Identifies Sharjeel Imam as Prisoner of Religious Freedom

NEW DELHI ---  The US Commission on International Religious...

Abhishek Banerjee Questioned for Four Hours over Social Media Post Targeting CEC Gyanesh Kumar

KOLKATA --- Trinamool Congress national general secretary and Lok...