Alleged Forced Conversion, Displacement of Tribal Christians: Delhi HC Declines Plea

Date:

Court says Chhattisgarh High Court is the appropriate forum as all alleged incidents and administrative actions relate to Sukma; it makes no findings on the allegations

NEW DELHI — The Delhi High Court has declined to entertain a petition alleging forced religious conversion, physical assaults and displacement of tribal Christian families in Chhattisgarh’s Sukma district, holding that the Chhattisgarh High Court is the appropriate forum to hear the matter.

A bench of Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma observed that the National Human Rights Commission’s (NHRC) headquarters being located in Delhi, and its having passed an order from the national capital, did not by themselves confer territorial jurisdiction on the Delhi High Court over a dispute arising in Chhattisgarh.

The petition was filed by Baman Ram Kawasi, who alleged that several tribal Christian families in Chitlanar village of Sukma district were threatened with violence and forced to leave their homes for refusing to convert to Hinduism.

According to the petition, on March 5, a group of people, including local panchayat members, entered the homes of Christian tribal families and allegedly gave them an ultimatum: either embrace Hinduism or leave the village.

When some residents resisted, two people were allegedly beaten with sticks and subsequently admitted to Sukma District Hospital for treatment.

The petition further alleged that the families were threatened with death, forcing several of them, including women, children and elderly persons, to flee the village and seek temporary shelter in Sukma town.

It also claimed that on March 17, the families were threatened again and warned that they would be killed if they returned to the village without giving up Christianity.

NHRC Refers Complaint to District Authorities

Alleging that the affected families had not received justice, Kawasi approached the NHRC with a complaint.

On June 9, the commission disposed of the complaint by forwarding it to the Sukma District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police. It directed the authorities to take appropriate action within eight weeks, involve the complainant and the victims in the process, and inform them of the action taken.

Challenging the NHRC’s decision before the Delhi High Court, Kawasi sought a direction that the commission’s order be treated as an interim measure rather than the final disposal of his complaint. He also sought a reconsideration of the matter by the NHRC after being given an opportunity to be heard.

Court Says Chhattisgarh Is the Appropriate Forum

Opposing the petition, the Centre argued that the alleged incidents, the displacement of the families and the alleged inaction of the local administration all concerned Sukma district. It maintained that the Chhattisgarh High Court was therefore the appropriate forum to examine the dispute.

The Delhi High Court accepted the jurisdictional objection, observing that the NHRC had not made any final determination regarding the victims’ rights or the veracity of the allegations. Instead, it had forwarded the complaint to the concerned district authorities and police for necessary action.

The bench noted that examining the relief sought by the petitioner would require consideration of events in Sukma, the role of the local police and administration, and the action taken in response to the NHRC’s directions.

It also took note of the fact that the Chhattisgarh government, the Sukma District Magistrate and the Superintendent of Police had not been impleaded as parties to the petition.

The court cautioned that accepting the argument that every NHRC order could be challenged before the Delhi High Court merely because the commission is headquartered in the national capital would open the door for disputes originating anywhere in the country to be brought before it.

It held that the dispute had its closest and most substantial connection with Chhattisgarh, making the state’s High Court the more appropriate forum under the principle of Forum Conveniens.

The Delhi High Court consequently declined to entertain the petition on grounds of lack of territorial jurisdiction and the principle of Forum Conveniens. However, it granted the petitioner liberty to approach an appropriate forum in accordance with law, including the Chhattisgarh High Court.

The bench clarified that it had expressed no opinion on the merits of the case or the veracity of the allegations of forced conversion, assault and displacement.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

SC Rejects Review Plea Against Demolition of Takiya Mosque in Ujjain

UJJAIN — The Supreme Court has refused to reconsider...

After 18 Months in Jail, Kerala Journalist Rejaz Sydeek Discharged from Two UAPA Charges

The special court in Nagpur has dropped charges under...

Delhi HC to Hear Fresh Plea Against Demolition of Krishi Bhawan Mosque on November 23

A worshipper has challenged the Centre’s authority to remove...