12 Years in Jail Under UAPA, No End to Trial in Sight: Two Muslims Get SC Bail

Date:

Only 68 of 197 witnesses had been examined in the 2014 case, the court noted. It also flagged that only two witnesses had been examined in the last one-and-a-half years

NEW DELHI — After almost 12 years behind bars without a verdict, two men accused of links to the banned outfit Indian Mujahideen have finally been granted bail by the Supreme Court, which said their continued incarceration was “grossly violative” of the fundamental right to life and personal liberty.

A bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta ordered the release of Mohd Saquib Ansari and Waqar Azhar on Wednesday (July 29), observing that the trial in their Delhi case has progressed at a glacial pace with no end in sight.

The Delhi case has its roots in an FIR registered in November 2011. During that investigation, Delhi Police claimed a Pakistani national arrested in the case disclosed the existence of a “Rajasthan Module” of the Indian Mujahideen that was allegedly planning strikes in and around the capital.

Acting on that disclosure, the police in 2014 said they recovered explosives and bomb-making materials from premises linked to Ansari in Jodhpur and Azhar in Jaipur. That led to two separate FIRs in Rajasthan.

Both men were arrested in all three cases in 2014 and have been in custody since. In one of the Rajasthan cases, they were convicted by a trial court in 2021, but the Rajasthan High Court later suspended their sentence. They had already secured bail in the second Rajasthan case. Their continued jail stay, therefore, was solely due to the Delhi UAPA case, as both the trial court and the Delhi High Court had rejected their bail.

The Delhi High Court, while denying bail, had observed that they were active members of the banned outfit and key operatives of its Rajasthan module with links to its leadership in India and Pakistan, and that this attracted the stringent bar on bail under Section 43D(5) of the UAPA.

Before the Supreme Court, the men argued they had already lost 12 years of their lives and the trial was nowhere near completion.

The prosecution had listed 197 witnesses, but only 68 had been examined. Even more telling, from January 2025 till July 2025, only two witnesses had been examined, and one of them only partly.

The court also noted that a co-accused in the same case had already been granted bail.

“We feel that the continued incarceration of the petitioners in this case is grossly violative of the right to liberty enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution of India,” the bench held. “The progress of the trial has been extremely slow, and there appears to be no prospect of the trial being concluded in the near future”.

Liberty as the Cornerstone

Reiterating a principle it has stressed in recent UAPA bail hearings, the court said that “bail being the rule and jail the exception is a constitutional principle flowing from Articles 21 and 22, and the presumption of innocence is the cornerstone of any civilised society governed by the rule of law.”

The court clarified that the severe restrictions on bail under UAPA cannot be read to allow indefinite pre-trial detention.

The court has directed that both men be released on bail, subject to conditions to be fixed by the trial court, and only if they are not required in any other case. It made it clear that its observations were limited to the question of bail and would not influence the merits of the ongoing trial.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

UN Urges Iran, US to Let Fertilisers Through Hormuz Before Millions Sink into Poverty

Before the conflict, a third of the world's fertilisers...

Iran Warns of ‘Immediate and Decisive Response’ to Any New US or Israel Attack

Tehran and Washington envoys spar at the UN, swapping...

Rajasthan Rail Track Blast: Two Hindus Held Over Suspected Links to Pak-Based Handlers

Police claim ISI contract used romance, money to recruit...