MLA Ketki Singh makes controversial demand for a separate ward for Muslims after video of prayers on hospital premises goes viral
Mohammad bin Ismail | Clarion India
NEW DELHI — A video from a government hospital in Firozabad in Uttar Pradesh has caused a heated controversy after a man was seen offering Namaz inside the premises. The footage, which quickly went viral on social media, has led to strong reactions from Hindu organisations and a controversial statement from Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MLA Ketki Singh, who has demanded a separate ward for Muslim patients.
Reacting to the video, Singh’s demand has intensified the debate. “Muslims have a problem with Holi, Ram Navami, and Durga Puja. Maybe they also have a problem receiving treatment alongside Hindus. I will request Maharaj Ji (Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath) to establish a separate ward for Muslims so that they can be treated separately. Who knows what will happen if they spit on us? We must ensure our safety,” she remarked.
Her statement has been widely criticised, with many accusing her of promoting division along religious lines. However, Hindu right-wing organisations have supported her stance, alleging that the act of offering Namaz inside the hospital was an attempt to assert religious dominance.
Following the uproar, the hospital administration has taken cognisance of the incident. Chief Medical Superintendent (CMS) Dr Naveen Jain has ordered an investigation into the matter, questioning the identity of the individual offering Namaz as well as the hospital staff present at the time. “Namaz should be offered in a mosque,” he stated, adding that the administration would ensure such incidents do not occur again.
Several Hindu organisations, including Hindu Vahini, have expressed their outrage over the video. Hindu Vahini leader Hridesh Sharma stated, “The administration has ordered that no new practice should be started. Despite a mosque being located near the hospital, offering Namaz within the premises is unacceptable.”
These remarks have further fuelled tensions, with right-wing groups demanding strict action against those involved in the incident. Some have even called for a review of hospital guidelines to prevent similar occurrences in the future.
Many in the Muslim community have condemned the uproar, questioning why religious practices are being selectively targeted. “People have prayed in hospitals before — be it Hindus, Sikhs, or Christians. Why is it an issue only when a Muslim prays?” asked a resident, Mohammad Arif. “This is nothing but an attempt to polarise society.”
Social activists have also criticised the hospital administration’s response, pointing out that medical institutions should focus on patient care rather than religious controversies. “Hospitals should be places of healing, not communal politics,” said advocate Shabana Khan.
The incident has cause political debate, with opposition leaders accusing the BJP of using communal politics to divert attention from pressing healthcare issues. “Instead of improving medical facilities, BJP leaders are busy creating religious divisions,” said Samajwadi Party leader Akhilesh Yadav. “This is a dangerous trend.”
Meanwhile, members of the civil society have urged authorities to handle such matters sensitively. “India is a diverse country. If people start objecting to every religious act, it will lead to unnecessary hostility,” said sociologist Dr Meena Raghavan.