Trauma of Women Riot Victims Lives On

Muzaffarnagar riot victims’ family members are still mourning and have taken shelter in relief camps in the villages.  --Hindustan Times photo
Muzaffarnagar riot victims’ family members are still mourning and have taken shelter in relief camps in the villages. –Hindustan Times photo

Mesum, a 16-year old widow from Muzaffarnagar, and thousands of other women like her are trapped in a nightmarish existence


Mesum, 16, a widow, kept herself covered from head to toe in a thick black sheet. She was on a three month-13 day iddat (mourning) ever since her husband was hacked to death by rioters in Muzaffarnagar district of western Uttar Pradesh (UP). She lives in a relief camp with her in-laws today and is not allowed to speak, be seen or even grieve without the permission of Ulema, who have laid down the code of conduct a widow must observe during this mourning period.

Like Mesum, there are scores of women, who are languishing in various relief camps across the district. They are struggling to regain control of their lives in the aftermath of the bloody riots of August 2013, which have been termed as the worst incidence of communal violence in the country since Gujarat 2002 and Assam in 2012.

As many as 10,000 people have been affected in the month-long violence that rocked the region although, predictably, it is the women and children who have borne the brunt of the destruction and displacement. Says Meena Soni, member of the Joint Citizens Initiative (JCI) that recently visited Muzaffarnagar on a fact finding trip to assess the effects of the violence on this vulnerable group, “Weeks on and the fear psychosis is more than evident, especially among women and children. Even a false rumor of a riot breaking out again sends spasms of terror through the camps and they instantly they break out into collective mourning and shouting in fear.”

Adds Azra Khatoon, another JCI member, who is part of a women’s rights group, “Women survivors remember the screaming mobs. They live in mortal fear of their threats become real. Even now they can hear the chants of ‘Musalman ki do jagah Pakistan ya kabaristan‘ (there are only two places for a Muslim, either Pakistan or a graveyard) in hushed tones in the camps, which creates a very tense situation.

As if that is not enough, in some camps groups like the Jamait-Ulema-e-Hind are issuing religious diktats. In one camp, Jamait members had decreed that everyone entering the area, whether a Muslim or a Hindu, will have to wear a burqa. Even we were not spared!”

Making matters worse is the fact that these internally displaced persons are refusing to go back home out of fear and so large-scale migrations continue to other districts and cities leaving village after village empty of people.

To address these issues as well as matters of safety, health, education and rehabilitation of the displaced women and children, the JCI – comprising women’s rights activists and health and medical professionals from New Delhi, Mumbai and Uttar Pradesh – visited different camps and later presented a summary of observation along with a charter of demands related to the immediate needs of riot survivors.

Informs Madhavi Kukereja, state coordinator of Lucknow-based Sanatkhada Samajik Pahel, “The JCI team visited camps in Bassikalan Madarsa, Kamalpur, Tavli, ShahpurMadarsa, Jogi Khera Shahpur Madarsa at Haji Ala Saheb’s Residence, Husainpur Camp, Loi camp, Kadla Eidgah in Kandla village (Shamli district) in addition to the villages of Phugana, Lisarh, Kutba-Kutbi in Muzaffarnagar and Shamli districts. We met survivors, members of management committees of relief camps and local residents from both Muslim and Jat communities and have been able to come out with a comprehensive report of our findings.”

Entitled ’30 Days and Counting… The aftermath of violence in Muzaffarnagar & Shamli, Uttar Pradesh’, the document clearly brings out women’s security concerns, including the unprecedented sexual violence they have experienced.

Pushpa from Vanagana, a prominent Chitrakoot-based women’s group, who also met with survivors, remarks, “The entire nation today is concerned about the safety of women, but it is strange how we are not talking about the brutal assaults they have undergone during this episode of violence. In our initial meetings with women survivors, while many of them bravely talked about the general pattern of violence, destruction of property and loss of loved ones, they fell silent on the issue of sexual violence.

Young adolescent girls were particularly reluctant to talk. Gradually, however, their confidence has increased and now women are not only speaking out, they are also seeking justice. At least five FIRs on sexual assault have been filed and many more women have spoken to our team about sexual assault of varying degrees and expressed a desire to file FIRs against the accused. It remains to be seen whether the state will aid them in seeking justice.”

Of course, whether or not the government expedites justice, the JCI team has recorded testimonies of sexual assault victims from village Lisarh (in Shahpur camp) and village Phugana (in Jogikara Camp) in Muzaffarnagar. These women and their family members are being pressurised to withdraw their complaints but nevertheless women activists are readying to move the courts on their behalf.

While sexual violence is a big focus of the report, it has also painstakingly documented the deplorable health conditions prevalent in the camps. Children suffering from scabies and dermatitis have been observed, clearly pointing to the fact that the health of women and children is not a priority for the camp management committees.

Says Deepa, from New Delhi-based SAMA, which works on health issues and took a team of doctors to Muzaffarnagar, “There is a public health emergency developing in these camps. There have been several deaths in Loi camp and over 67 pregnant women in one camp alone are facing a grave future, with virtually no access to medical care. Most pregnant women we met were already anemic and underweight and the conditions in the camps would only aggravate their vulnerable state. Even those who had delivered in the camps lacked proper food to meet their nutritional needs. There were no Auxiliary Nurse Midwives (ANMs), no gynecologist nor any women doctor from the government health units to examine them there. We observed a complete lack of antenatal and postnatal care in the camps despite the fact that women were suffering from various problems such as leucorrhoea, micturition, fever, urinary tract infection (UTI) and anemia.”

Moreover, Deepa reveals, while there was no separate space for deliveries, “we also noticed that the newborn babies were mostly of low birth weight and that no immunisation services were made available to them.”

Children have been faring no better. As per Askari Naqvi, a social justice lawyer from Sanatkada Samajik Pahal, who plans to represent cases of sexual assault and neglect of women and children in court, “The worst affected by the lack of proper medical care are children. At the Loi camp we saw eight deaths within a week due to poor medical aid. It was heart rending to see a four-day-old child die in the absence of any care, five children succumb to diarrhoea and fever and a 14-year-old girl bleed out during menarche. These are the worst human rights violations we have ever seen.”

The JCI report, presented to Javed Usmani, Chief Secretary, UP government, triggered an immediate response. An enhanced compensation packing has been approved in addition to the setting up of a working Special Investigation Cell as well as the assurance that statements recorded under Section 161 of the Indian Penal Code for tracking missing persons will be followed up diligently. All of these were part of the charter of citizens’ demands. Additionally, the JCI team has also called for provision of health care in camps and the immediate tabling and passage of the Communal Violence Bill 2011.

When and how Mesum and thousands of other women trapped in their nightmarish existence will resume their normal lives is anybody’s guess right now, but it is imperative that the state government understand the human tragedy that is unfolding in these camps and act without any further delay.—Women’s Feature Service


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here