Time for Civil Society to Move In And Rescue The Hopeless Situation


Amit Shah and Narendra Modi


Humra Quraishi

NO matter how hard I try to view from the glass half-full angle, but just can’t. As nothing seems to be going fine. No sudden eruption, but an ongoing decline right from the summer of 2014. In fact, we have reached such a hopeless situation that nothing really shocks. Perhaps, in these recent years we have been witnessing too many perversions, deprivations, human disasters.

In fact, soon after the Modi government took charge, the masses awaited miracles to take off, as promised in the speeches at the political rallies, but only severe setbacks and bigger disappointments held out. Correct me if I’m wrong but 2016 will be remembered as the year of ‘notebandi’ (demonetisation). One of the biggest setbacks for the citizens of this country was demonetisation. And in 2017, Mahatma Gandhi was ‘removed’ from the charkha and his place ‘taken’ by Narendra Modi. Shots of Khadi Udyog’s new-year calendar had hit many and public outcry followed: Even Mahatma Gandhi not spared in these fascist times!

And even as the establishment continued to come up with those hollow development slogans, anger had started spreading out. In 2017, for the first time in the recent history of India, farmers travelled from the far-flung regions; reaching New Delhi, squatting right in the midst of the capital city, focusing on their plight…Today, of course, our farmers are protesting at the Delhi borders and in several states of the country. The farmers are upset and angry with the very passage of the three Farm Bills.

In fact, in these recent years we have witnessed less of governance and more of distracting tactics — surgical strikes, war cries, setting one community against the other, new names for cities and townships, unspared even the roads!

The deterioration continues, with unemployment and the economic crisis overtaking everyday life. Communal violence has been accelerating as never before.

And in the midst of fears and apprehension, displacements have been taking place. In these recent years I have been interacting with those displaced from the rural stretches of North India. Mind you, forced shifts in the rural belts are pointers to bigger disasters. After all, when communal politics reaches rural stretches and hits the poor, it reeks of eerie build-ups. Yet, today, entire families are getting uprooted from their base! With the State standing as a mute force or as a collaborator!

And with hunger and deprivation on the rise, the masses do not want to hear any of those stale speeches. Enough! Only freshly made daal-rotis will do. But where are those everyday survival basics? Nowhere in sight!

Unless civil society moves in and tries to rescue the hopeless situation, our young face a very bleak future. Hunger, deprivations, injustices are hitting the young as never before. With the future holding out little respite.

In fact, in certain regions, the so termed conflict regions, the young haven’t seen a single day of peace. There’s been only violence and counter violence, where locals as well as non-locals, from all possible communities, get killed.


Well, the ground reality has turned so very pathetic that the popular outlet Fabindia had to withdraw its ad – Jashn-e-Riwaaz! Why? Because some of its clients or buyers or the communal characters around, didn’t quite okay the Urdu sounding Jashn-e-Riwaaz!

This is the dark reality of the day. So well seeped in is the communal poisoning that even an Urdu sounding word or term or phrase is not to be tolerated by the right-wing men and all those characters who are following them rather too blindly…The stark reality of the day is that this ‘connecting language’, Urdu, lies crushed and deadened in the midst of the communal virus spreading out as never before.

Around 2005, I had met a researcher, Valerio Pietrangelo at Jamia Millia Islamia. I was a visiting professor at that university and he was pursuing advanced study of Urdu and Arabic from the University of Rome and had travelled to Jamia Millia Islamia as part of his research work on ‘Partition Literature in Urdu, Written by Women.’ With that in the backdrop, I’d asked him to comment on the Indian Muslims he’d been meeting and also his comments on their mother tongue, Urdu. Valerio was forthright, “As my main concern has always been Urdu language and literature, my contact with the Muslim community in India has always been filtered by my perception of the language issue. My impression is that Muslims are in a certain sense a backward community, at least many of them. As I met Muslims, I realized how dramatically they are shifting to Hindi and other Indian languages since government is not promoting Urdu language and literature. I think language is an essential element of group identity, therefore, I feel that Muslim identity is threatened.”

And Khushwant Singh minced no words, detailing the slow death of this language, “Urdu is dying a slow death in the land where it was born and where it flourished. The number of students who take it as a subject in schools and colleges is dwindling…Apart from Kashmir, where Urdu is taught from the primary to the post-graduate levels, in the rest of India it is the second or third language. With the passing of years, it has come to be dubbed as the language of the Muslims, which is far from the truth.”

Khushwant would recite these verses of Urdu poets Rashid and Khurshid Afsar Bisrani, focusing on the near-death of Urdu.

Rashid’s verse: Maangey Allah se bas itni dua hai Rashid / Main jo Urdu mein vaseeyat likhoon beta parh ley.

(All Rashid asks of Allah is just one small gift / If I write my will in Urdu, may my son be able to read it.)

Khurshid Afsar Bisrani’s verse: Ab Urdu kya hai ek kothey kee tawaif hai / Mazaa har ek leta hai, mohabbat kaun karta hai.

(What is Urdu now but a whore in a whorehouse / Whoever wants has fun with her, very few love her.)

In today’s India, Urdu stands reduced to such lows that knowledge of Urdu cannot ensure employment; nor the basic means to survival. This treatment meted out to a language that carries the subtle power to heal and control emotions and much more long the strain –- A study conducted by the Lucknow-based Centre for Biomedical Researches (CBMR) published in an edition of international journal ‘Neuroscience Letters’ states that reading Urdu script and Urdu couplets helps in brain development. This report, based on extensive research, goes to prove that learning and reading Urdu couplets helps in controlling emotions, coping with stress, delaying dementia. It could also be helpful for children with learning disabilities.

I can say with much confidence that another positive is this — Urdu couplets, dripping with romantic strains, carry the ability to distract one from the dark realities of the day.

Perhaps, this particular verse of Sahir Ludhianvi relays the stark dark truth of the hypocrisy ridden times we are surviving in:

The same cities where once Ghalib’s voice resounded

Now have disavowed Urdu, made it homeless

The day that announced the arrival of freedom

Also declared Urdu a cursed and treacherous language

The same government that once crushed a living tongue

Now wishes to mourn and honour the dead

The man you call Ghalib was a poet of Urdu

Why praise Ghalib after suppressing his language.


Humra Quraishi is a Delhi-based writer-columnist-journalist. She is also the author of several books including Kashmir: The Untold Story. The views expressed here are author’s personal.

Clarion India - News, Views and Insights about Indian Muslims, Dalits, Minorities, Women and Other Marginalised and Dispossessed Communities.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:




More like this

Karnataka Muslims Protest Renaming of Tipu Circle after Savarkar

Clarion India BENGALURU - The Tipu Sultan Samyukta Ranga along...

Woman Thrashes Man with Slipper during Hindu Mahapanchayat on ‘Justice for Shraddha’

NEW DELHI - A woman thrashed a man with her...

Mumbai: Adani Properties Bags Dharavi Slum’s Mega-Makeover Bid

MUMBAI - In a significant development, Adani Group's Adani Properties...

Aarey Forest: SC Allows Metro Corporation to Seek Permission for Tree Felling

NEW DELHI - The Supreme Court on Tuesday allowed the...