Is the India story over?


Chidambaram-and-MukherjeeBoth Chidambaram and Mukherjee are accountable for the current economic mess. They should explain why they took the steps which disturbed the rhythm of progress

By Kuldip Nayar

That India is an economic mess is known all over the world. What is not yet public is that the malaise was because of the wrong decisions which President Pranab Mukherjee took when he was finance minister from January 2009 to mid-2012 and also when finance minister P Chidambaram was heading the ministry nearly till the end of 2008 and before.

Mukherjee lives in the luxuries of RashtrapatiBhavan and Chidambaram shields himself behind tall promises he still makes to mend the economy. Both of them are accountable. They should tell why they took the steps which disturbed the rhythm of progress. Because of lack of transparency in the affairs of government, only a handful of peopleknow about the blunders the two committed.

One of the decisions taken by Mukherjee was to impose the Rs 1200 crore tax with retrospective effect on a foreign mobile company. After having lost the case in the Supreme Court on September 8, 2010, the government promulgated an ordinance before amending the Finance Act 2012. The retrospective clause in the act has scared away foreign investment which India badly needs. A bagful of concessions has not brought the Walmart yet to the Indian soil. Foreign investors have withdrawn a large sum of money which they had invested. In a few weeks, as much $ 200 billion has reportedly gone out. The outflow has not stopped yet.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh did not anticipate the repercussions. In fact, after seeing the mess Chidambaram had created in 2008, the Prime Minister should have taken over the finance ministry himself because of his expertise in economic matters. Unfortunately, his own record as coal minister does not hold promise but the prime minister would have done better in finance. India should have been exporting coal, as it did, instead of importing it. Manmohan Singh may not be personally responsible for the corruption in the allotment of coal blocks. But the bungling runs into thousands of crores of rupees. The full story may not yet come out because some files are missing. The government has admitted this before the Supreme Court.

According to CBI (Central Bureau of Investigation) as many as 157 files are missing. The missing files reportedly have some letters and noting on the allotment of coal blocks. The prime minister cannot absolve himself of the responsibility that he was not the custodian of the files. He was in charge of the coal portfolio. A top CBI official, who is probing into the scandal, has said that there may be a need to ‘examine’ the prime minister, who was in charge of the ministry from 2006 to 2009. Could the prime minister have connived at what the ministry had been doing because his personal integrity is beyond reproach?

The Prime Minister could have done something to bring the culprits to book but he could not because he is politically weak. His other fault was that he depended too much on Mukherjee and put him as the chairman of several committees of Group of Ministers, entrusted with the task of finding solutions to intractable problems. Unfortunately, Mukherjee had no time for his own ministry and the situation began deteriorating. The crisis has been aggravated by the galloping inflation (10 per cent). An average person whose income had remained what it was even as his expense has gone up because of the ever-increasing price of essential commodities. His cost of living would have been still higher if the government was not subsiding petrol, diesel, cooking gas and the like. According to IMF, the 20 per cent of the top in India enjoys more subsidies than the 20 per cent below.

The elite are too powerful to be touched. Top business houses finance many MPs who see to it that no harm comes to their houses. LokSabha elections are due in 10 months’ time. On an average, a LokSabha seat requires an expenditure of Rs 10 crore. The political parties are already in touch with the business houses for funds. How can they challenge them for their malpractices? This is confirmed by the unanimity all parties in staving off the chief information commissioner’s ruling that the RTI (Right to Information) will be applicable to the working of political parties.
Yet the immediate problem is how to get over the present financial crisis. The prime minister has himself admitted in Parliament that “the country is facing a difficult time”. It can justifiably be argued that the bungling is because of the government.

There is no governance, no leadership and no guidance. I do not know what reforms the prime minister has in mind. I wish there had been fresh elections, as I had argued three months ago. The uncertainty which puts off investors would have been over by now and the people would also have settled down to a new elected government. But MPs of most political parties, particularly those of the Congress, want to enjoy the full tenure of five years. Many of them know that they may not be reelected.The anxiety over political scene is casting a shadow on the future. Unless there is a sweep by one party, which does not seem likely, the next government will also be a coalition.
It may not be in a position to take hard decisions which India needs to overcome the deepening crisis. That the political parties should have the consensus on basics goes without saying. But this may not be possible before elections. But that is what the country needs whether it happens now or later. May be, I am on the wrong track. Probably, the story of India looks like over, at least for years.

Clarion India - News, Views and Insights about Indian Muslims, Dalits, Minorities, Women and Other Marginalised and Dispossessed Communities.

Share post:


More like this

No Social Media Display of ‘Qurbani’: Islamic Centre’s Advisory

LUCKNOW - The Islamic Centre of India (ICI)...

The Party Which did Bhakti of Ram and Became Arrogant was Stopped at 241, Says Indresh Kumar

JAIPUR - Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) ideologue Indresh...

Lucknow Demolition Drive Continues Amid Inadequate Resettlement Plan

Team Clarion LUCKNOW – The demolition drive in Muslim-majority Akbar...

WB: Fill 3,000 Madrasa Vacancies in Three Months, HC Directs Govt

The court also imposed a fine on the Madrasa...