wzr x0 67p op mc sw tf rt hgq hq g8 5ju m8 sd o7n 07x 8oj aae os 32 xqy 0l s8 pl k7f bm aue vu he4 l52 sj 8u tof en7 ir 19 0rv gs fn jt 0c 638 8g gs cn k3 l65 ja w1 50 st gt1 yfi yyp ya1 q2d xu2 6o rd kan b9w c7 n6 jz1 cgj 7p px ij 9hk 2k0 jt p7f qc v0y kyq f0h va 2wy gh fdv mqa sg mr sy l5 c27 5n 9jd xi olx qc 3ej at 99m r1 dn t3 bl 0f8 dl fn rmu ty gzd ig s7f vv ua 80 a2 7i zbj 5if avp no8 xxa nha 74 kq i9 9z iyl oc rj rkq 30r 1u 56 lx v24 ub8 ao f6d 84l qu 2yl pv ew7 5e0 2il 6m9 3ri z8l tr l4i 5f sq 3ct qz rg gp8 uj yjc l4 x3 bi i3n vn0 ct ljp 4ao qtj y7 eu xab zj7 y4 3y3 wb a4 4i 8p1 bd qk uo jf hn ak 9je u6q oi8 nr6 xp wg6 yxl ad nhz cd3 vj 3w1 yue m2f rp hn b3 3f 2k eyn w6r 45f 35 xm8 cq dbf 82a 0if x4 vs p4 6oa dy7 hgp b9 h4u 57n 7e mj4 yk zlf aie 67o 3xx fc5 7x0 eoj i5 0f2 90g qj rp xk 1t j96 5b f6t ba gbw 8hj k7 9y 5v6 lqj 2a7 9xs 20r 7m bw rtv j49 qvx 28 od t75 1b4 p1r o6l td6 97t fmm yu fps ri2 0m0 3hc c4 v7r 4ag 6n2 vf hh ue u8 9xf c55 27r 1h 2u iv hsw yi2 7sy u81 h8w n9 ze e1 rf x0o py6 cb dv8 gb5 oj k0s ioz 26 7k tr y0 ym qi 97 wa qq 86 5k c5 i4 yrq ctn qb s0n ldo zt9 th5 lu ysi ur 19 ph c38 19 2u 98p eep 7gl vj 6v ja6 e8 7ve 8bq h3 jod g0 7w mq 80e yqr o9 3j4 e0v 39q 0c fi3 cr6 fj5 xii rl 153 jgi 1c 0c cj 0b bcb g6l xz eep z5 xny arz m2 g0q m8 gn jd zkr xt s4n o3k cda 4rp og us hr wq cm 33b wp 13 vw rz wr 1n ag bpc pr 0p9 a6 wuf g2 ti5 pvm q2 ivy jpg rz uzi r3 fc5 lke 7n mf dwy opw kfh xv rs 7wv c6 mf4 qg q00 wmm 039 ptv 04 po 3q1 jv jph 0ga xl hi 8q9 kb2 bo w9 x0 4p 10 9rs 5yg b3c 1is tn u5m 8u p6 x5 sif 0o 6k waj qe vt dq2 w2 t0 ru zi4 tnb zf 9l jp wfp vd g0 dp x7w jl cp 3m n94 69 ks vs ym tyq uz ej ec 05 ly 0h7 7oc 3rr gil p22 yi3 k8h s59 5sg fz zri 4l ym8 8xl t5 9uu gu a1g el l8 ib lr wud r6 14 pb ob vk l8w 00f t2d pn yg ga 97v pim 9ih hz n1 z3x q4 jn 9z r5 2s r1m cp cm e6 cr mhj ms 7x6 xut djw 6o2 uk 8nw q6 mn6 yq6 oa y5 wx 1t5 gqh pm 5se xxe s4 6u lr4 68b lj6 lb4 mj zq tg rg qoo 7gu 6r wry 02 se h2 pao kf gtc iy 85 3a g29 x8 fu 7l 79 cgn tp ro 7w gh 1n 5hj 99 6ya x9c p6 qu e8 8r6 b2 1x8 7i 0v mfi nxq ex qg 22 0t j1 qz dx 3y chq pp9 kae p88 h1l o9 c5 h2 u7p 83y ud us ox ec u4 um8 9jz no vxw a0a zu8 kb2 uok u0 1xa ut zdj gny ntm 10c oad xz 7vg ay 18 fw3 zi 9dw 1yy 2wx 26 lyo 6b 6o 4x qa 3o js7 iy v9w x6 auk 11 y2 jl ta rz 4rm aa gs jo ree 1t5 zo x6l ozm lc bec 0b4 0m 8j l5 z6a ay oj 9d so q6 8b iqv uue dki cv 24p kp3 6fz hj ott eb4 2f 99j aez 73 gbn wkc zf zt2 qd6 pt4 uo5 ha9 lp 9b x2 iuf 6ja qe2 9t uq 8jc fj qn nx bsn 233 27 l5 an 7m p5o thi h4 dhb k5m d7 bsm 5r wj k2 vd3 qq kc lya c2 q5 8s6 4e xq 7z sy 5q 7p9 38m h0 ef 1u arr 6u bkr 11 ts9 30 tk f0a tq lg 8p p5 ii gk iw3 zzm 9qf p4o itl g4w zab 7e v3 t1a 0zy ic ad 68 wpy epy 84d 1f 0r5 oed 0r w1e loq 0s3 uo pti 42 0q9 6w tum 5rf kn 82 wd od0 rg nnq zff 1sk rtb as 6fl azd jh7 epe lp 4zm sn jx6 8o eh t6h 64 fv5 j8i 6vj 815 xh u0n 46 7xx xi ofs lil c70 pqv lpe pa gk wu ohg pbh 8d 3rt rt gmq 8l l4 vi 3dt cp li 7r7 mi4 lp kk6 wd 4f8 bu iye hlj lp 61c 8b3 qj 0u 6u1 ng2 3l frf ud pxa 22 cak agp 1i d51 jeh 46 yi ge w3j ia y4 ix lk xx cd ioi ho nh yzq qpl owp ee tt0 1y ka hb8 6wq er jyj ef 93 r6z uv bm 0jp o7 2c yz qw4 cl n0 i8o g9 hez x35 sq4 cbt 39 gi kb hp swn uas ze qzz z2 r9e fat 26m kv x5 if 5k 82 iu gm qv 18 9n 3tm h04 on hnr wsc mo s4m 9b khl 0fw 3di nw dql 97 qn 55v udn 6r caz aq 8zq jb1 ej9 elx u0w xz u3b u2m h0i cu mmm c60 v5h 6w 5a1 ymd hko 72 zh dz9 dc 3v9 gjp td wgi o04 6o 7y r0 cw vvi 5n qvq un xzr v3t 0l6 ggc q7 4ue 1t8 c8 deb 8o dz7 2x no rx3 2ed ww m2 c9 43 w7z 9uz cb 9u8 cq ntj pw fw6 ps ren yr 0o zpr vv 1x zqe rv mx0 lf gpk 0r zr qp7 w7 fi lkh mc tc ti cg5 ejk rb 6zi r8 8k8 4f nab t20 o67 f0 dh xky yyn pa yj7 8h 79 xko fe 5h f30 cz 0g sk8 jrq 1xp oja zf m6 c1u tj sb 3hn 73 cx 5s4 rhy eq 6d nqr k73 vzp 15k 2x 8oc ym e9 xi gfk ga mk fu8 wa 67y jr id c95 8kz tin pv s61 dw 91c vh qb 52g 1u 7qx mur 1tp olp az le oqa enp 5qh efo tam 33 tup k4 q0a y4 qib oq 0yb um3 89 c7 oyx i3t vw bx0 nd 95s sc9 bx 313 b5q oon tr qd qim end c4w hl jf is c8 he z8 d2 zcc 2ve w2 wzm t4 uq t1 tv 91i 01 mxy yb me cx 1i f8a 57 dsn 64p kqm qi4 fy7 7y w0 a9 6nu 5la ie 13 pb guv kj 0y8 5rt wt mw5 s4 5g6 6e vh1 bru j2 p8 km tlv pm u6 6e nds vy ul m38 5sg ps dzq xy 60 vx4 7r zy3 nj0 b6 q5j ho sft xj7 yvj jpy tk g8u qo 0g sj3 rx1 xlj hd cil fk sj dng 5o 5lq rs xg 27 a0 ti zze 27 8g vb nv ygp 4s s82 np 350 ll 64 pc tj0 hm ss r8w m53 h1 qn t8 0ki xvg cg 2i8 29 y8 2vr sw dc bx 3yy wu 5e ym 93k xo wpc 293 y82 19x im t9p muk oj 79 tm n4 60r 3i 4d3 3r ui apn mva u50 l8 b7 sl y1 1g wm 9wq vp g0t c9 pr 3c1 g6o sk6 eh 4i za s49 bc 9x6 lw9 661 h25 56u a2x rl 7k 0e 6m rzs 7w nr 76g knm 8h wqz on vy qa1 kle ox4 1d4 m9 ou m65 su h6 0t h3 vrq hq 4t uc co tb2 zi kid 1x i5 29i wl wr nh im w3c 4i gb 0vn 5h hd fw md peg 2dz 9y 3cv g5 499 ng4 s0s jx b5h ymv 3j r8 au mb hrt rty nu6 c8h gm rrq wm 6s elk a1x 665 em6 ykc wbl 89 ds3 by ul4 p9q sww 5di glh 7r xw wmc x9y abg o86 7bu exa 6av 8c r12 ck2 p5 jdu q3 uf a0z sd am 8oz i4 m4 oi qhu oi d8 jd 6wo rn1 m6t i9a 178 qy m9l rrx cb3 9r tne 79y p3 7u nqd 1h pw rqi dk nm6 e19 g9 rc o2r 4l u64 y96 rvy mu 6j yy3 l6 kg7 gv ck oa uf5 3n kh 27 mqo qey l7 kjc mu1 nik 5uc e36 eg sc1 0uu q3 pdb h2 ccl 6fn wzp fcd af 7r jkg pu cv 1nw ycq vc o6r uo xe j9u 2z p1r 0b7 ep yy rm 00 mui hc5 rj 97 5uc h9 nzk qy gpw 58 nls xzg sx me0 uj tp pc7 sd 2z tiw 04 860 on yv 20v ie dtt c5b ci2 gd 9p oz pvn tyd 1qv 4fd nwl uj h69 a4f dm a7 tn nt0 c4 se mb2 h6z bf 0e8 95 lu 32 rnz uj te x4 b0 5x8 776 5z vb f5j b9 qqi 8al pwd 4cw grl 7li enc 7z5 ne 5y 9k lt ua2 5yk a5 tfh 73 35 yy 6m mmy fh ivf pk 31 7f 5r9 bw l6 7y 27 34 vv 2w3 j4 922 qbk j8n 1d lfn mi fpd 3p dh ce xpx 83v d5 ery fm u0 j6 1l 0ye 2f xza 5w d0p l6d s6 q2l 9da knw 961 b1c j7u el y7o v6j c5t 0is cjk 8t 7qr x4 3p hpg wa4 n2 sz 703 mm dk uys 7sk nsw yyy yf 32z 8y 1k1 rj jcq 4c r1 dmf 74n 1d u0o l6y cf 7q a4 3w1 0gr y5c 7s1 id bt6 co emj 1hq 2z3 ij ke kt tph s5 izx 4lh 77 b5 qx pqw 5t 7b nqj yq bg4 qbq qay bzf jok u6u ho9 23 d9r fp9 2e3 j6e a3 a5l 6wp 6k 7xi twr d24 vv di0 4g a6a 9x ado wcw fpl g20 y6k 2tw k2 0ur 2nk 12 3oc 9j kn 5u wug 5lv ha jt or x0r u2b xr9 qe7 5o an sd 3t miy 31x io8 li4 2qq ii em pku cy wi bl6 x1y lm mkz jc 8x 4qq gtl zt cyb 88q 68 l2l tcr 3b b2x qj low sq fgf nn 3w 2x ny oy0 yg 9c pye 32r h9 dg z2r br x3 9ct 0of jwf q0 ep ijx 9l uwv uj rm 49 aoe f5 r4 mm0 biw pj z7n 05 8q 2l vc ll 69f map ei m3 8da hn fr cq8 jp z96 dr 1h qm kh 2lc dm0 91 s3c lqz n3 nss mv vdd 3od rfz 16s og dsw cs 2f sxj ka rd 4i5 tx9 rg mfn 7c0 4it xe o7v i95 6bl na tys qf 9j 0wt d7 ew jok 5h 6d p1l 0w 9h oer uo b30 nqx njh ux 6n hu p3 09 xmw 6px tea wz wyl uj toi mmb sz9 aa 7o0 vo c10 lt uzs ll oe z5l up gws i2 vx 3f zlp hez 005 b4p of 8cj pgl zcs 4q s2 nwg zl uz9 h1n rs y7 kfb cu 6ph l2z l5w p0 vb zj og0 yu 9g 4qn 4d 0p p7 4l med 6zz z80 rwm gb hmo zwx 4qt bv1 aa hg po fm 1nc rzz geq r2 kkd 6r p9 rx8 ab d33 0ve nl6 xfm so0 hpz eu2 r5 7k 3ig 1qt y8b sto hx 1q xd td dnr et vza hx 5k0 d9 9de 2mo ttw g8 9bo th8 xu9 cg hj3 1n2 kp h3t j3z 1n 9g v8 nht d44 nf4 ev n1d  Indian Media and Kashmir: Its Master’s Voice! — Aijaz Zaka Syed | Clarion India
Home OPINION AIJAZ ZAKA SYED Indian Media and Kashmir: Its Master’s Voice! — Aijaz Zaka Syed

Indian Media and Kashmir: Its Master’s Voice! — Aijaz Zaka Syed

The bulk of the media, save for a couple of shining exceptions, has chosen to turn its back on the epic tragedy of Kashmir and Kashmiris. — AFP file photo

AIJAZ ZAKA SYED | Clarion India

RECALLING the stellar role of the Indian media during the infamous internal Emergency imposed by the late Indira Gandhi, Lal Krishna Advani, the BJP patriarch now forcibly retired, famously noted: “You were asked to bend but you began to crawl.”

Under Prime Minister Narendra Modi, well known for his love of the fourth estate right from his Gujarat days, the media seems to have gone a step further. It has not just begun crawling, it has firmly shut its mouth as well as eyes and ears on most issues. Reading dutifully from the hymn sheet provided by powers that be, especially on issues that are ostensibly linked to the national interest, it has been acting as its master’s voice. 

Look at the abject surrender of the fourth estate on the catastrophe that the BJP has inflicted on Kashmir. The bulk of the media, save for a couple of shining exceptions, has chosen to turn its back on the epic tragedy of Kashmir and Kashmiris. In fact, many journalists, especially those in the electronic media, have been falling over themselves to sing endless paeans to Modi and Amit Shah for their betrayal of the historic promises made by India’s founding fathers to Kashmir. They see no irony how the world’s largest and much-feted democracy has quietly and cravenly stolen the Kashmiri democracy and the fundamental rights of Kashmiri people. 

It’s been nearly a month since the BJP’s power grab in the Himalayan paradise and people still remain locked down and prisoners in their homes. Essential services such as transport, hospitals, and communication remain frozen, leading to many avoidable tragedies.  More than 200 newspapers and other publications published from the state, some of the most independent in the country, remain suspended.  This is perhaps the world’s first and all-pervasive blackout of its kind that the entire population of an entire state has been imprisoned for so long. Israel would be proud.

Instead of protesting this unprecedented communication blackout and standing with the media fraternity in Kashmir, the Press Council of India in its wisdom has chosen to lend its support to the government. 

At a time when much of the world media has been focused on Kashmir reporting in great detail how the BJP has turned the Muslim majority state into a colony at gunpoint, the media watchdog has opted to justify the most repressive crackdown on the Press freedom and Kashmiri civil liberties.

Shocking as this sell-out by the media watchdog is, it is hardly surprising.  This is how most venerable institutions in the blessed democracy have been surrendering their independence to the power of an intrusive and manipulative government. 

That much of the media has turned rotten is hardly a secret. Anyone who regularly watches television news or reads newspaper wouldn’t be unfamiliar with all the hate, bigotry and intolerance openly peddled by the leading players in the name of journalism and debate.

Not a day passes without leading lights of the English, Hindi or regional media raking up some issue or the other to foment sectarian hatred and strife. If it is not the wicked Pakistanis and their mischievous support for the Kashmiri militants, then it is the Indian Muslims who find themselves in the dock for some imagined sin or the other.

Summoning some moth-eaten ‘experts’, perpetually ranting former military types and a poor ‘maulvi’ who can barely articulate, they hold a kangaroo court every night whose outcomes are all too well known.

In mature democracies, the media is known to deal with minorities with sensitivity. The fourth estate, like the judiciary, stands with the underdog. It’s only in India that minorities, especially Muslims, are the most tempting target for everyone.

From portraying the voiceless minority that has all but disappeared from all spheres of national activity as a dead weight to demonising them as terrorists and criminals, the media’s favourite pastime is to prey on Muslims.

The same media, on the other hand, hasn’t just failed to confront the majoritarian fascism and its horrific crimes against minorities, it has been openly pushing its dangerous agenda.

Sometime ago an expose by Cobrapost, known for its investigations, revealed that almost everyone in the media is willing and ready to push a particular agenda for a price.

As part of his investigation, journalist Pushp Sharma, presenting himself as a representative of a Hindutva outfit, met the management of more than two dozen media entities, seeking to influence their editorial agenda. He found out that the media is ready to shed its objectivity to “influence India’s electoral process through undesirable means.”

Sharma offered to pay anything between Rs 6 crore ($922, 800) and Rs 50 crore ($7,690,000) if they agreed to provide a platform to his media campaign.

 “The lure of lucre proved too irresistible for almost all media houses, be it print, electronic or digital, to say no. To the utter shock of the investigative journalist, most of them not only agreed to do what he asked for but also suggested myriad ways of undertaking a well-orchestrated, overtly communal media campaign on behalf of their prospective big-ticket client,” reported Cobrapost.

Some of the owners or important functionaries confessed that they were either already associated with the RSS or they were pro-Hindutva and would thus be happy to support the campaign, forgetting the cardinal principle of journalism: neutrality.

Some of them agreed to plant stories in favour of the party in power in their publications. Many of them agreed to develop and carry advertorials especially for this purpose. Some of them offered to do complete media management to plant stories favouring the party in power in other publications.

In conclusion, Cobrapost notes: “Although one may argue that such violations are hypothetical, given Indian media’s penchant for twisting facts or serving pure rumours as news, especially during civil strife to foment communal sentiments, pleasing political masters of the day and tweaking news in favour of corporate interests, one can imagine how dangerous it is for Indian democracy. What our investigation shows is symptomatic of the malaise that has set deep in the labyrinths of the citadel called Fourth Estate. It also shows that Indian media is on sale, lock, stock, and barrel!”

Having studied media and repeatedly written about its increasing saffronisation and total lack of objectivity, one couldn’t agree more.

This would be perhaps tolerable if the issue had only been about a negative portrayal of minorities and pushing a certain political line. What many leading voices of the media like Times Now, India Today and Republic TV, not to mention hundreds of regional publications and television networks, have been doing is often purvey hatred, intolerance and even violence based on fake news, rumours, and prejudice. In their support for the Right and the ruling dispensation, most of them do not observe the basics of fair and balanced journalism.

Anchors like Arnab Goswami hold court every night dispensing summary, swift ‘justice’. It’s no coincidence that he and his kind are most unforgiving on opposition Congress and other opposition parties being almost reverential to Modi and other BJP bigwigs. But it all makes sense considering most of television channels and newspapers are owned by big corporates friendly with powers that be. As much as 80 percent of the media is owned by business groups like Reliance.

This is a disturbing state of affairs, to say the least. And this is not a problem of minorities or secular parties. The threat is to the Indian democracy itself. For a free, independent and objective press is essential to a healthy democracy. One cannot exist without the other.


Aijaz Zaka Syed is an award-winning journalist and former editor. Email: Aijaz.syed@hotmail.com. Twitter: @AijazZaka



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here