Hindu groups demand punishment over temple video; police act swiftly to avoid communal tension
GHAZIABAD – A Muslim police constable in Ghaziabad, Suhail Khan, was suspended for reportedly posting a video from a temple during the Hindu festival of Janmashtami. The video allegedly included a religious message, triggering a public outcry.
The video, recorded at Bapu Dham under Madhuban Police Station, showed Constable Suhail standing inside the temple and posting it online with a message saying, “Only Allah is worthy of worship and no one else is worthy of worship.” After the clip went viral, Hindu groups, including Hindu Raksha Dal, demanded strict action against him.
Pinky Chaudhary, national president of Hindu Raksha Dal, publicly expressed her displeasure on Twitter, tagging Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath and senior police officials. “We demand immediate action against this officer for hurting religious sentiments,” she wrote, urging authorities to respond promptly.
Ghaziabad Police Commissioner, aware of the controversy, acted quickly to suspend the constable and assign him to line duty. Senior officials explained that the decision was made to prevent any potential communal tension.
A senior police officer commented, “Our priority is to maintain law and order. This action was necessary to ensure that no religious unrest arises in the city.”
Legal experts and community observers have noted that while Suhail’s personal belief is protected under the Constitution, posting religious messages in an official capacity can be controversial. ‘While everyone has the right to faith, government employees are expected to remain neutral in public duties,’ said advocate Farhan Siddiqui.
Many in the Muslim community have expressed concern over the disproportionate reaction. Local resident Ayesha Khan said, “Suhail Khan is a devoted officer. The video was personal expression of faith. It does not harm anyone, yet it has been politicised unnecessarily.”
Historically, Indian Muslims serving in government roles have faced scrutiny for expressing religious identity, often attracting criticism from right-wing groups. Observers argue that the Ghaziabad incident highlights ongoing challenges for Muslim officials balancing personal belief with professional responsibilities.
The police administration reaffirmed its stance: “This is not about religion but about following rules for public servants. Our goal is to maintain peace and prevent escalation.”
While the suspension has sparked debate online, legal analysts suggest that such cases raise important questions about freedom of expression versus duties of public officials. Some human rights advocates have urged authorities to focus on intent rather than provocation.
In conclusion, the Ghaziabad case underscores the delicate balance Indian Muslims must navigate while serving in public offices, especially amidst heightened communal sensitivities. Constable Suhail Khan’s suspension serves as a cautionary example of the pressures faced by minority officers in India.
