Defeating the Politics of Hate in India

Protest gathering at Jamia Millia Islamia on January 1, 2020

Hindus, Muslims, Christians and Sikhs are all on the streets to denounce this government and to save the secular India that Gandhi envisioned.

Dr SAMINA SALIM | Caravan Daily

UNIVERSITIES have always been the incubators of revolution. The anti-war movement of the 1960s in the United States, resistance to state repression in China during the 1980s, and the Arab Spring in the Middle East during 2010-2014, all owe their existence to student revolution. What we are witnessing in India is an example of yet another student revolution in the making.

It was December 15th, 10 AM Houston time, when I woke up to videos and pictures of young female students of Jamia Millia Islamia shielding their male friend from brutal attacks of Delhi policemen, students of Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) being shot at, beaten and assaulted by Aligarh police — images so powerful, that two weeks later they remain vividly engraved in my mind. This weekend students of Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) were attacked and assaulted. But why the violence?

On December 11, 2019, a Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) was passed in India. According to this new law, the Indian citizenship will be provided to Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi and Christian minorities from the neighboring Muslim majority countries of Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan. CAA supposedly functions in-tandem with the National Register of Citizens (NRC) which had rendered 1.9 million Indians stateless in Assam, of whom 0.5 million were Muslims.

File photo used for illustrative purposes

Imagine the chaos upon nationwide implementation of this law. NRC will first segregate those who cannot prove their Indian citizenship and will declare them as illegal residents, including Hindus. CAA will then allow all — except Muslims, to be eligible for citizenship. All non-Muslims who were excluded in the NRC, will be embraced through the CAA. The NRC is useless without the CAA, and the CAA is meaningless without the NRC. The CAA has been implemented, and the NRC will also be implemented soon according to the Home Minister Mr. Amit Shah.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi, however, contradicts this and falsely claims that a discussion on NRC never happened and that the public outcry is simply a fear mongering tactic of the opposition. Regardless, this new law violates the secular principles outlined in Article 14 of the Indian constitution, which prohibits using faith as a condition of citizenship. This is what the students are protesting against. India’s youth has risen to save the holy book of democracy, its Constitution. The fearless resistance and unabated courage exhibited by students of JMI, AMU and JNU have added a whole new dimension to the geometry of world’s largest democracy.

There was a rebellious undertone among the Indian youth for quite some time now; the CAA proved to be the cheap sequel to a horror movie which already had been playing in the country for a few years. Since PM Modi’s Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party came to power in 2014, lynchings of the country’s minorities have surged. Human Rights Watch reported 44 murders during 2015-2018, and hundreds more injured in religiously motivated attacks.

According to Reuters, a total of 63 attacks occurred in India between 2010-2017, in which 24 were killed and 124 injured. Most of the victims were Muslims. Other victims included lower-caste Hindus and Christians. Attackers are described as devout Hindu men, known as “cow vigilantes”. In simple terms, these are Hindu fanatics fueled with hatred for Muslims, who are on a mission to kill anyone who is engaged in cow trade or eats or sells beef (cows are considered sacred in Hinduism). These are not some lone misguided men in an alley gone rogue, but they operate with a full cheer-leading squad.

Tabrez Ansari who was beaten to death in Jharkhand

The perpetrators openly film their barbaric acts, and share their savagery with social media. Tabrez Ansari, a 23-year old young Muslim man was filmed while being assaulted for hours, forced to chant Hindu religious slogans and finally lynched. He died on June 22, 2019. Pehlu Khan, a 55-year old Muslim man was filmed for hours while being lynched. He died April 1, 2017. On June 22nd, 2017, 16- year-old Junaid Khan was lynched and killed, and four others injured and thrown off a moving train. While the lynchings are atrocious in and of themselves, what is even more sickening is that the cow vigilantes are being rewarded by political parties.

The slogan “Save a cow, lynch a Muslim” does not seem to mesh with the compassionate Indian culture. In the backdrop of rampant lynching, demonitization was introduced by Modi government. This exhaustive exercise — marketed as a pragmatic move — ruined the livelihood of the common man, while black money largely remained unaffected. Now, the Modi government can’t figure out a way to ventilate the struggling Indian economy.

India is going through a growth rate decline to a six-year low of 4.5 per cent, with the lowest employment rate recorded in the last 45 years. To distract the public from the struggling economy, the Modi government decided to revoke Article 370, a section of the Indian Constitution which allowed Kashmir, the only state in India with a Muslim majority, a degree of autonomy. The government called this as an instrument of economic boom for Kashmir.

The world is watching, has anyone noticed any economic boom in Kashmir? It’s almost comical of the Modi government to talk about the rights of displaced Kashmiri Pandits, but never care to comment on the plight of the pundits of Varanasi and Ayodhya, wandering on the streets often hungry and homeless, some making less than a dollar a day. Then, another strategic distraction from the economy — a Supreme Court verdict on the 16th century Babri Mosque, permitting construction of a temple in place of the masjid, a renowned historical structure. The decision was hailed as a victory for the Modi government.

A woman with her nephew in Srinagar. Indian soldiers have forced most Kashmiris to stay at or near home as govt had imposed heavy restrictions and lockdown after the abrogation of Article 370.

While the Modi government is focused on settling issues of 16th century, farmers in 21st century India are committing suicides, due to dire poverty and lack of government support. Crime against women is so alarming that the UK and the USA have issued travel advisories to women tourists, with some naming India as the rape capital of the world. More than 32,500 cases of rape were registered with the police in 2017 — about 90 a day, according to the most recent government data. Indian courts disposed of only about 18,300 cases related to rape that year, leaving more than 127,800 cases pending at the end of 2017.

Clearly, demonetization, Revocation of article 370, the biased verdict on the 16th century Babri Mosque and the passing of the unconstitutional CAA, all combined could not cover up government’s failures — unemployment, the sinking economy, judicial, social and moral collapse. The students have taken the lead and are out on the streets protesting and demanding immediate repeal of the CAA. They have inspired thousands to join.

Muslims, Hindus, Christians and Sikhs are all on the streets to denounce this government and to save the secular India that Gandhi envisioned. CAA is just a symbol of their unrest. The Indian government is propagating its usual hate rhetoric and labeling this agitation as a “Muslim issue”, but in the eyes of a peace loving Indian, this is an Indian issue, a human rights issue. The government has opted an approach too reminiscent of despotic regimes-intimidation, curfew, orders to not assemble, tear gassing, police brutality, social media trolling, and stereotyping.

Just the other day Hon’ble PM made a derogatory comment on a protestor’s attire, referring to the hijab and head coverings of some of the protestors. What the PM and his hate mongering supporters cannot stomach is that people of all faiths are part of this agitation, and they are not pleading on behalf of any particular community, they are simply empowering the truth. Their fight is to defend the constitution and preserve the democracy in their country.

There should be no illusions about what the deterioration of established democracies could mean for rest of the world. As Dr. King said, “Threat to justice anywhere in the world is a threat to justice everywhere.”

Samina Salim, Ph.D., is Associate Professor of Pharmacology, University of Houston College of Pharmacy, Houston. She was born in Lucknow and raised in Aligarh and moved to the United States in 1999. The views expressed are author’s own and Caravan Daily does not necessarily share or subscribe to them. 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here