JAIPUR — The Rajasthan Assembly witnessed sharp exchanges after a ruling party MLA described the Azaan broadcast from mosque loudspeakers as “irritating,” triggering anger among Muslims who termed the remarks selective and hurtful.
Raising the issue during Zero Hour under Rule 295, Hawa Mahal MLA Swami Balmukund Acharya claimed that loudspeakers installed on mosque minarets in Jaipur’s Walled City exceeded permissible decibel limits. “The loud sound affects students during examinations and disturbs the sleep of ordinary citizens,” he told the House.
Acharya alleged that residents often face resistance when they request mosque committees to reduce the volume. “Complaints are made, but no strict action follows,” he said, adding that the problem “worsens during Ramadan” due to the use of additional loudspeakers.
Speaking to reporters outside the Assembly, Acharya said his objection was not directed at prayer itself. “I respect all religions. The issue is public inconvenience,” he said, claiming that women and local residents had approached him with complaints.
Muslim residents and community members strongly objected to the tone and framing of the remarks, saying the Azaan has been part of Jaipur’s soundscape for generations and lasts only a few minutes. “Calling the Azaan ‘irritating’ hurts religious sentiments,” said Abdul Rahman, a shopkeeper in Johri Bazaar. “Noise rules should apply equally to all — temples, religious processions, and political events included.”
Community leaders pointed out that existing laws already prescribe decibel limits and time restrictions. “If limits are violated anywhere, action should be taken uniformly,” said Maulana Imran Qasmi, a local cleric. “Singling out one community creates fear and mistrust among minorities.”
Students also weighed in on the debate. “Examinations are important for us too,” said college student Sana Khan. “The Azaan lasts for minutes, while loud DJs during rallies and festivals often go on for hours.”
Minister of State for Home Jawahar Singh Bedham said any action would be taken strictly in accordance with the law. “Loudspeakers must remain within prescribed decibel limits,” he said, adding that the matter would be examined. He noted that issues related to minaret height and construction fall under the Jaipur Development Authority and municipal by-laws, and necessary steps would be taken if violations are found.
Rights groups urged restraint and impartial enforcement. “Maintaining public order requires balance,” said advocate Faisal Ahmed. “The right to worship and the right to peace must both be protected, with rules applied equally and without bias.”
